Advertisement
Please wait...

November Discussion Post: Which Creepypasta Would You Like to See as a Movie?



Estimated reading time — < 1 minute

This month’s discussion post topic was suggested by YOU CAN’T HANDLE THE USERNAME!, and it’s an interesting one:

Of all the Creepypastas/Crappypastas that you’ve read, which would you like to see as a film? Do any specific actors, actresses, directors, composers, etc, come to mind for your imagined Creepypasta movie adaptation? Would it be a short film or full-length?

Advertisements

Have fun with this, and thanks for the idea, YOU CAN’T HANDLE THE USERNAME!

Advertisements
Please wait...

Copyright Statement: Unless explicitly stated, all stories published on Creepypasta.com are the property of (and under copyright to) their respective authors, and may not be narrated or performed under any circumstance.

1,058 thoughts on “November Discussion Post: Which Creepypasta Would You Like to See as a Movie?”

  1. I think that many films could be created but id like to see if they could do the format of the youtube series MarbleHornets and each film could be like that, “Jeffs Mystery: the stories of a killer” “Janes misery: the other side of the story” “The Proxy Trials” “Times Up: ClockWork” “The Ticks In The Story: the story of Tobias Rogers”. I can see it now!!!!! this could appeal to almost all creepypasta lovers and horror lovers alike!!!

  2. CharChika Rishi

    I already thought of this when i read Psychosis. That is a perfect story for a sci-fi movie. I could imagine it playing as a movie when reading it.

  3. diddlydiddlydooda

    I’d actually like to make a Slenderman movie. While I realize that it’s a bit used up by now, I feel like with all the lore on the internet, it could be really interesting, and maybe truly terrifying. But if I had to choose another one, it would definitely be Ticci Toby, or the Bloody Painter. Their stories are interesting, and depending on your situation, they can be really relatable. So yeah.

  4. Phantom Marionette

    I Thanked the Man Who Murdered My Only Friend.

    It’s well written and has enough back details about the characters that I think that it would make a good short or full movie depending on who directs and writes out the script.

  5. I would like to see:
    On a hill as a short movie:
    I imagine Leonardo DiKaprio as John and as the narrator – Johnny Depp

    Slum as a full-length movie:
    For example as Nunez – Idk, Will Smith came in mind :D
    Rusty – Jennifer Lopez
    Marisol – Chloe Moretz
    Thad – Chandler Carterbury
    That’s what I think will look good :)

    These pastas were my favourite and I would love to see them into movies!!!

  6. I think they should have a tv series titled CreepyPasta and every week they show a “come to life” version of all the top rated pastas.. I would watch it every week.

  7. I think a movie about Ticci Toby would be cool. It should be a fair length film not to long but not too short either. No actors or directors have came to mind yet though

  8. Candle cove as a short animated film (I’m totally thinking of making this!)
    Other than that I’m still waiting for the marble hornets movie :(

  9. Deadlynightshade

    Bedtime, love, Lord of the scarecrows and the singing of the scarecrows would all be great as a movie.

  10. All the pastas in one movie(top pastas, e.g jeff, slenderman, the rake ETC.) and all of their backstories, then they meet eachother and go on a killing spree. Something like that

  11. Id personly love to see ascension in a movie it has almost everything including a great plot antagonist and protagonist

  12. It would be interested if the Creepypasta Smile.jpg was turned into a short series, like the victims going into desperation, and spreading the word but starting with the original beginning.

  13. -=+=-PowerTeam-=+=-

    I think that Jeff the killer would be a great movie to see because of all of the fighting scenes in it. Also it would be cool to see what Jeff looks like

  14. I think “Seer of Possibilities” by Thomas O would make a terrifice movie! It is extraordinarily well written and even has the length and plus some relevant content can be added since it does skip a couple of years. It gives of an eerie sense which would be excellent for a scary movie. The ending will also be great and could possibly lead a sequel!

  15. I could definitely see the no end house! throw in some more to the plot and pow! A good suspenseful scary movie!

  16. Never read dust but I say nooo, you guys suck bedtime with all the parts or ubloo, but with an ending leading to the final depart of ubala leaving the mortal plane for a suspended amout of time, I think it be an awsome movie along with bedtime my 2 favorite pastas so far, id like some other really goodnpasras

  17. Three words. Was who phone. Not in that order. I just messed up your brain.

    But an actual good pasta the movie would be The Sandman. Or one of the zombie pastas, those are the coolest if done right. I think an actual creepypasta movie would be awesome.

  18. I would LOVE if Ticci Toby would have a movie. It’d be interesting to see! Plus my last name is Rogers. I’m honest! It would be amazing to see how an actor can act out having Tourette Syndrome. I’d lke it

  19. i think it be cool if there was a clash kinda like Jeff vs Jane it be an interesting concept on Jeff’s background as well as Jane’s but we don’t get much of others background thus implementing a prequel/sequel to Jeff’s and Jane’s past and could bring another clash with Jeff and slender man

  20. I feel like this brings up a larger question; because my favorite creepypastas are more psychological than physical like “persuaded” but I know that they wouldn’t be able to produce a full hour of content without becoming boring or repetitive. Also I can’t say that I trust Hollywood to not try too hard with more physical pastas and produce a hour long crud fest with slenderman fighting Jeff the killer or something.

    But if I really had to choose I would choose “persuaded” because it is my favorite but it would take work to produce it well.

  21. Psychosis would be a really awsome movie. And if the actor would really capture the lead character’s paranoia it would an awesome movie to watch. And the story is very engaging.

  22. TBH they should make a slenderman movie then jeff the killer then a movie where they fight and then the rake but a lot more action

  23. I think the Harbinger Experiment would be a perfect movie. It’s detailed, it’s excellently written, it’s scary, it’s believable, realistic, and classic. It’s everything a good story should be. It deserves a lot more attention than slenderman or Jeff the killer. And besides that, Slender basically already has a film adaptation of you take Marble Hornets into consideration and a lot more fan made films other than Marble Hornets. Which honestly is great also. And I think by now we all know that Jeff the killer was set in the universe of DC Comics and Jeff and Jane grew up to be the Joker and Harley Quinn. They healed and had plastic surgery to alter their appearances.

  24. I’m pretty new to the creepypasta scene but if this discussion is still going I think that the pasta ‘On a hill’ by Michael Whitehouse would be the most promising story to be a movie, I just couldn’t stop reading

  25. So far I would think “Mr. Widemouth” would make a great movie. If more details were added, it might be a good full-length movie.

  26. Gotta be the ubloo series. Anyone who has read the whole thing knows how amazing the story is. If you havnt, go read it now and youll understand

  27. Marilyn Creepypasta

    Clockwork, she might make a good movie besides the scene “she dodged the doctors’ bullets and charged after a doctor and killed him”.
    No, just… no…
    be realistic

  28. Marilyn Creepypasta

    Toby and Jeff the Killer, I think, would be really interesting ones (besides all the 80’s names in Jeff’s)

  29. Either jeff the killer or the rake i love them both but i love jeff the killer more so please do jeff the killer!!!?

  30. someoneyoumayormaynotknow

    I would like to see a jeff the killer movie with nina the killer and jane the killer maybe slenderman, ticci toby, masky, and eyeless jack

  31. In all honesty I think Jeff the Killer would make a good movie as would Smile dog, but I feel like some of the more realistic and unrecognized CPs would be great as well because there is more to relate to, also the fact that it “could happen” adds an ominous/ scarier effect.

  32. Is it just me, or should there be a film called ‘Proxy’? Because Masky, Hoodie and Toby are too awesome and even people who don’t know what creepypasta is, know about slenderman.

  33. xXxEmmaSuweenxXx

    Yes I agree with those who say there should be a movie with Slenderman and Jeff the Killer along with Jane through out the movie. Or maybe just a movie about how Jeff refuses to kill someone and they end up having to stay a Slender mansion forever, and how the others like Ben drowned and Ticci Toby, Sally and E.J. will ajust to it.

  34. EYELESS JACK OF COURSE!! He’s the best!♥Mmm….No or Jeff the killer.Well actually i wanna see his brother Liu too…Bet both r cool and handsome…

  35. stereotypically I would want to make a movie about jeff the killer (or at least a jeff the killer-esque movie). I already have the script and the idea but I just wish I had a high up company to represent it.

  36. I think the rake would be good as a movie. but instead of a movie my thought would be a television series, but don’t make it like a detective show. There would be some detective work but the ones that get closest to solving it will get killed.

    Tell me if that sounds like a good idea.

  37. I feel like the rake would be a good movie theme to make, they made something similar already but I feel like it should be the rake. they made quarantine and thats almost like the rake but idk its missing the fear factor that the rake was.

  38. Jonah Otterbein

    My favourite choices would probably be The rake, 1999, Jeff the killer or laughing jack. They’re my favourites :D

  39. AudreyTheKiller

    i think jeff the killer could become a full lenght movie if you think about it… it wouldnt be that short if you put some everyday life conversations with liu or something when there at the bustop before those bullies came and then add on to the fight… maybe even have jeffrey’s mom trying to make jeff feel better after liu left… and when jeff finally gets rid of his parents we could see a bunch of other moments of other victims… and for actors….. i know he isnt an actor but maybe if its possible : PinkStylist could be the jeff the killer actor… :)

  40. I think maybe On A Hill it would transfer over well to a movie it would take some time but it might work tell me what you think.Another would be Abandoned by Disney And Room Zero,maybe they could change the title to something else but it might work all considering Disney doesn’t have a problem with it.Next,(note this isn’t really a creepypasta but is much like one) PENPAL,If you haven’t hear of PENPAL just look for Creepsmcpasta’s videos on it or read the book.The book has more details but is slow paced.Finally The Showers,just read it or listen to it.

  41. yes, this topic is very old, but candle cove would make an awesome movie. say, a child begins watching a show, candle cove. blah blah and it really doesnt exist. then when he is older the characters begin to haunt his dreams, so he commits suicide. the end.

  42. slenderman and his proxy’s woulde make a good movie (along with being a good haunted atraction) and also jeff the killer could be to
    I would really like to see ticci toby in a movie or haunted attraction

  43. Creepypastashewrote

    I think slender man would be a great movie, because of it’s scare factor. You could have a little girl brushing her hair, when all of a sudden BAM! Slender man is on the scene, while the girl is screaming. Her parents rush upstairs and faint at the sight of slender man. He hisses and leaves. But, the best part is, that YOU would be Slender man. It would be sick! I would also like to see Super Mario 64 as a movie. It would be fun to create a corrupted file ON PURPOSE!! Anyway, the idea would be great, but it must be a short film. Or else, the fun will go out of the movie.

  44. why bother asking. JEFF. most views most discussed and by far most amazing you can add in Liu and Jane IT WOULD BE FABULOUS DOLL

  45. I think five nights at Freddy’s I mean it’s a really creepy game and some people say that it’s haunted so I think it could be a movie

  46. but make a jeff the killer story that intertwines with jane the killers story and when jeff runs off after killing janes and his parents he runs into the woods with his dog”smiledog”and he meets slender and his proxy

  47. jeff the killer& jane to make the movie longer aand intertwine and at the end slender meets them “honestly io thing somewhere in there would be a badass movie , but not just slendy his proxy too

  48. what about the rake that would be so cool and have slender be like the cotroller of the rake and some guy has to fight the rake and find a way to stop slendy

  49. Jeff the Killer could definitely make a good movie, it would be more simple rather than doing special effects for Creepy Pastas like the Slender Man, or the rake (although, if Hollywood decided to invest the money in those, I’d be happy). They could also do the proxies of Slender Man, or maybe even Eyeless Jack, or Laughing Jack! But just like the stories, the movie must have limited jump scares, I want it to be creepy for the plot, not the jump scare.

  50. 1999 would be interesting due to the fact of the grotesque and unusual nature. It would be very amusing to witness. I love the whole idea about it. Candle cove seems really interesting as well.

  51. Lelouch Vi Britannia

    i would really like to see jeff the killer made into a movie and maybe even slender and/or jane in it as sort of side characters

  52. eyeless jack……Kellan Lutz would play Jack…who’d be the lead role…….the girl who played the flegdling vampire from my babysitter’s a vampire would be the second lead role….she’d play a girl named Mary……….Jensen Ackles could play the boyfriend who dies……Jared Padelecki could play the bff who dies……And the plot twist could be Eyeless Jack could be a friend of the lead female role who turned out to be a cannibal and after Mary Killed him came back to life and is seeking revenge……this’ll be a full length movie

  53. Really, I’d like to see Jeff the Killer, with Kim Kardashian without her make-up playing Jeff… and I’d like to see “The rake” be a short documentary, because crazy people believe that stuff, so…

  54. Slenderman would make a wonderful, dark, and horrifying movie. Its such a big pop culture icon, and i know there’s a fan made movie that proves its chance of being successful.

  55. Well… Personally I’d love to see BEN drowned as a movie, but Jeff the killer would make a nice one too. They could make BEN’s past revealed. I mean like seriously, all I know is that BEN drowned.

  56. Psychosis. It’s long enough, and the ending is great. The screen writer could add more “incidents” to make it long enough for a movie. The perspective and writing thing might me difficult to pull off and the end might have to be changed a bit so it’s not awkwardly done.

  57. bob joesbergenstine

    maybe it could be a t.v show or some thing where every other episode is a differnt pasta and the famous pastas are like the season finalies

  58. I would think the proxies as in Maskey, Hoddie & Ticci Toby would make an interesting horror movie. They could do the back story of them and how they became Slenderman’s proxies.

    Another idea would be maybe, a BEN Drowned movie and it should be a 3D movie and, it would be how the main character found the legend of zelda haunted majoras mask also the movie can take you into the game where BEN is how he feels in the game, whats it like etc.

    An Eyeless Jack back story horror film maybe?

    Jane & Jeff the Killer also Homicidal Liu movie..

    My last suggestion is a horror film of all the creepypastas how they live in the Slenderman mansion….

  59. it would be cool if all the most famous pastas (like Slenderman, Jeff the Killer, BEN, etc.) come together for a movie. i’d watch that

  60. Am I the only one that wants to see someone make the Candle Cove show into an actual T.V. show or movie?

  61. angel_the_peacemaker

    i think jeff the killer would be a good movie to make even though it would be very very gory!!!

  62. i think the first movie if they make one they should make the movie kind of like creep show and tales from the crypt put four creepypastas into one movie and call it creepypasta and put jeff the killer laughing jack slender man and the rake in there then have a creepypasta 2 and put eyeless jack ben drowned ticci toby and smile dog then creepypasta 3 the final installment since creep show only had three movies and the creepypastas are alot like those i think the third movie should have sonic .exe mario 128 squidward’s suicide and suicide mouse to end thing’s off and scare the crap out of people

  63. Holy crap, “Penpal” would be the single greatest creepypasta-turned-movie. It’s not on this website, but MrCreepypasta did some videos on it. It was the first Creepypasta that I actually found entertaining. The author, Dathan Auerbach (or 1000vultures), turned the story into a book and has received great ratings from refers and critics alike.

    Quick summary: Throughout his life, a boy experiences terrifying events caused by not a monster nor demon, but a living human being. Each part/section of the story is an account of a different period in his life where he experiences these strange and disturbing events. Some of the time he’s too naive to know what’s going on, but eventually he figures out…

  64. The Rake. I believe it would make a truely terrifying breakthrough in the movie business, as the most horrifying film ever to be created. With the right actors, computer graphics, and screen writting, it would most likey be banned from releasing it in a few countries, but satisfy my search for a fact-proclaimed “horror film”.

  65. The Asylum series, or even just Psychosis.
    Director that comes to mind is Aronofsky.

    Wouldn’t want any huge famous actors in it. Would somehow lose the effect, I feel.

  66. CreepyDuck! >:)

    I would love to see Jeff The Killer as a movie. This may sound like a typical response, but this story has the potential as a movie. It has lots of descriptive words that can definitely make the movie even better! I would watch it if I had the money.

  67. Ronald mcdonald house by james cameron with brad pit as victim and some random unpaid actor as ronald and brad escapes and is chased and ends up going back willingly and killing ronald, that’d be so epic

  68. the harbinger experiment could be an amazing movie you don’t have to change the basis it is truly terrifying and i could see the potential for an excellent opportunity to scare traumatize and make the truth come out

  69. For those of you saying, “I wish Jeff the killer was a movie!” The closest you’re ever going to get is the film, ‘the Pumpkin Carver’

  70. The_Amazing SAF

    I don’t think that Creepypasta movies would go over to well. I just think that they would come out feeling rushed, or not enough. Remember, some stories have the same story, but conflicting histories. I think they’d come out better if adapted to a tv show, because that would give more time to develop characters and stories, not to mention that by doing a show, you could adapt more than one story.

  71. Jeff the Thriller

    I think Jeff the Killer would make an excellent movie. I would love to see how it would come together, and what the story would be

  72. Alastair Cunningham

    If a movie were to be made about creppypastas, I think it would be cool to see it in a Sin City way. Not specifically the black and white look (though that could work) But tell a story of a different individual, related to the creepy entities. One for Jeff, one for Slendy, one for Ticci Toby, one for Laughing Jack, etc, and have a narrator telling the story along. I think that would be cool.

  73. Definitely the Harlequin series. That would be an awesome movie. There’s also a creepypasta I read elsewhere called The Disappearance of Ashley, Kansas that’s really good. I could see a movie being based off of it.

  74. Second Impression: Actually just remembered this one: The Harbringer Experiment/Project/whatever it is. Watching people get ripped in half to Tiny Tim would proove freaking hilarious. Sick, but hilarious.

  75. Psychosis would be interesting to watch as a movie, just to see how they would do it, and to see who gets the role of our unfortunate main character, driven mad by… madness. And that one part with the eyes (not wanting to spoil it), I want to see how that happens… It’s sick, but I still want to see it.

  76. I know Ticci Toby is not on the website anymore but I think Ticci Toby would make a good movie. Ticci Toby or Russain Sleep Experiment.

  77. The girl in the fox tail

    Ticci toby or clockworks story would also be a good movie and maybe BEN drowned would be a good one too

  78. I would pay to see Stephen Haris’ Harlequin Series from the first (“Harlequin No.7”) to the fourth/last story (“Dirty Paper Machines” was it?) on the big screen.

  79. Why not just make CREEPYPASTA into a whole film studio/enterprise? Creepypasta films etc etc.

    If this does happen tho I’m totally on board with a Ben Drowned adaptation.

  80. I think all people should just really think of what the public wants………
    p.s. I have never heard of russian sleep story

  81. and possibly Hypnos Lullaby, Smile Dog, the Rake, Squidward Suicide,Jane the Killer, Slenderman, Ben Drowned, BRVR, and a whole lot more!

  82. I would LOVE to see Jeff the Killer as a movie! I dont know who would play Jeff though, but it would be awesome! That awesome catch phrase “Go to Sleep” It would be amazing!!!!

  83. InfernalNightmare333

    I’m not a big fan of Jeff the Killer, but I can totally see him starring in an old-school slasher flick; one of those movies that’s just a bit hokey, but aware of it. Something like The Russian Sleep Experiment, Tulpa, the Harlequin series, or the Story of Her Holding an Orange would be great as a more serious, complex movie. I’d also like to see the “Case File” series (narrated on Youtube by MrCreepyPasta) as a movie, but I don’t know if those stories are on this site or not…

  84. Lord Corvell:
    I imagine Dust could be made into a movie quite easily… It is so well written, it just feels like it could be adapted really well with very little change.

    Others however, like Candle Cove… Those would probably be a lot harder without changing the basic idea of the whole thing.

    Whichever, though, I’d prefer short film. Those are the best at driving something home, and leaving a lasting impression. At least that’s my opinion.

  85. All of them, i mean it’s quite logical considering the poorly thought of as well as cliche’ movies they are coming out with recently. Yes, they are still good, although they are running out of idea’s and the movies end up resembling past ones. They remake and re-do everything so I believe making multiple creepypasta’s into a movie would be the most logical idea. Actually I just want to watch them, my response sounds smart though :3 Maybe they will be like “Oh, yeah that makes sense, let’s do that!” although truthfully they would probaly be thinking “I don’t get it but it sounds logical, sure why not!”

    1. BecauseICan:
      All of them, i mean it’s quite logical considering the poorly thought of as well as cliche’ movies they are coming out with recently. Yes, they are still good, although they are running out of idea’s and the movies end up resembling past ones. They remake and re-do everything so I believe making multiple creepypasta’s into a movie would be the most logical idea. Actually I just want to watch them, my response sounds smart though :3 Maybe they will be like “Oh, yeah that makes sense, let’s do that!” although truthfully they would probaly be thinking “I don’t get it but it sounds logical, sure why not!”

      Precisely!

  86. maby one about ben drowned and how the guy who made it made it.It could be called.the ben doumechry.or what ever

  87. I think the Rake should be a movie. It would be the ultimate stalker. I hope it is made!

    I would definitely pay money for that kind of movie. It should be pg13 or R.

  88. SMILE.DOG!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!possibly The Rake, too. oh and The Devil Game!

  89. Mr. Narwhals:
    I agree. Jeff The Killer would be a great movie.

    oh my gosh, i’ve thought that for a long time.
    they’d have to erase some of the plot-holes by adding some things in though, which most jeff fans would hate

  90. Jeff the killer,this is the one that popped in my mind for obvious reason but i also think that slender man is a good one too, there are a lot of youtube series about slender man and slender man is known largely, slender man is how i got into creepy pasta, needless to say Jeff the killer is amazing I think that Jeffery the killer or Jeff woods would be amazing to see as a movie to see how a causal teen turns into a homicidal killer ,if i had to pick either slender or Jeff, id pick a movie with both or them ,because slender man makes you wonder as a person ,what revolves around this creature and the paranormal and even tho Jeff isn’t a proxy of slendy, Jeff has some many characteristics about him :) one way or another i think creepy/crappy pasta is amazing and if any one story/myth / whatever you wanna call them would be an amazing movie

  91. I’ve started doing the research and it sounds like everyone would love to see creepypasta films. Would anyone be willing to donate to a crowdfunding campaign to see them? You be part of helping brings creepypasta to life. I’m looking to into do a web series based around creepypasta. Without funding things like these wouldn’t be possible. For donating, the person donating the money would be entitled to certain perks. I’m really interested in creating web series. Please get in contact with me if you are interested.

  92. i know this seems copied about a tv series but they should take all of the pasta’s and put them in a series like first they have i don’t know eyeless jack episode then jeff the killer or a part 1 then 2 of 1 and on holidays a battle of the top 2 creepy pasta’s this holiday month

  93. Beware of Those Who Would Do You Harm-I loved it, and I think it would make a pretty good movie that would appeal to petty much all audiences, there’s horror, then a bit of romance, and suspense and would be a really thrilling movie to see.

  94. FangirlingaboutTicciToby

    I think a Movie about Ticci Toby would be AWESOME & LOVELY!!!! Now you get my username :3 Yes I love Ticci Toby he is my favorite Creepypasta ever

  95. I think the devil game would be a great movie, though It would have to be a story to do with it since the creepypasta itself is essentially instructions

  96. Jeff The Killer would be a pretty good movie and maybe afterwards, if they make JTK they could Produce a Movie about Slender-Man. It would Be a Really GREAT to see these two clash on screen like AVP And King Kong VS Godzilla.

  97. Psychosis would definitely make an awesome film! The creepy atmosphere throughout would be so easy to create with some low droning music and the plot twist at the end and just ugh… Would be so good :3

  98. Well, I’d rather have Jeff the Killer than the others. Like, about the sad things he goes through but then, when you figure out that he killed your like O-O…. I DID’NT KNOW HE HAD SUCH A TERRIBLE BACKSTORY! (srry 4 the caps)

  99. String Theory has potential, funnymouth would be amaysing, and bedtime but i feel like it would be better off read than watched.

  100. The Jeff the killer story would have a huge turnout if it were to play out on the silver screen. I’d certainly go and see it. Finding an actor to play Jeff himself however wouldn’t be a simple task.

  101. I don’t know if this has been suggested yet and I do apologize if it has. I could see a documentary, found footage style movie on The SCP foundation.

    1. The russian sleep experiment would be cool. It would make abetter film if it went dayafter day. it would be possibly a ahour and a half if each day lasted about 2-3 minutes. Significant ones would last about 8-15, and afterwords, Bendrowned would haunt the commander, and eventually kill him and he would think hes the subject. Just my opinion

  102. jeff the killer would be a great movie , such as the rake , eyeless jack , ben drown , slendy , and jane the killer. jeff and jane would be 1 amazing movie , 2: eyeless jack and the rake , 3 jeff and jack , last slendy by himself .
    jeff would be the next jason because his movies can carry on , with part 1 part 2 part 3 and more , suggest jeff and you guys will be amazed .

  103. maybe you could put all of them in a movie? i would so watch that. espically if it had BEN Drowned he is mah faveorite.

  104. Interesting Enough

    To grow interest in this site and what have you: A group of friends and I are creating a Jeff the Killer movie, careful to use exact and accurate details and character descriptions and most importantly: Personality of the characters.
    Thoughts?

  105. I’d love to see squidwards suicide released, like it was made, because from the picture and the pasta it’d be really creepy and probably better than ordinary spongebob by miles x.0

  106. Jeff-The-Killers-no.1-fan-ever

    I think Jeff The Killer would be a AMAZING MOVIE and/or SHORT FILM

    Mostly because there are so many great actors for it

    Jeff – Jhonny Depp
    Liu – David Tennant
    Margeret – Janet Jackson
    Peter – Peter Capaldi

    etc.

    PS. JEFF IS THE BEST CP EVER!!
    PPS. JEFF IS HANDSOME ETC. ETC.

  107. I think that Jeff vs Jane would make a good moive if not something involving candle cove, maybe even Zalgo. There’s just ALLOT of legit stories and charaters that would make agood moive … though if I’m to choose just one, then I think that maybe it’d be intressting to see ALL the imfaous charaters that have made it to fame.

    kinda (for example) as if a altarnet limbo like world began top leak into ours pouriong out these monsters and emotions, taking over humanity … if that dosen’t make it to a theater I will PERONAILY create it!!!

  108. I’d absolutely love to see Laughing Jack, Jeff the Killer and BEN Drowned as a movie.

    If they made Jeff the Killer as a movie they could do a Freddy VS. Jason kind of thing with Jane and Jeff.
    That’d be awesome, actually c:

    1. Isn’t he a bit old to play a teenage boy?

      I’d put money on that one kid from American Horror Story if JtK was ever somehow made into a movie. I can’t recall his name, but he’s been in every season.

  109. The Russian Sleep Experiment would definitely make a really good movie.
    I would have to say a Jeff The Killer movie would be pretty awful tbh. First of all, Jeff The Killer is really just an over-hyped Pasta. It was good at first, but after awhile it just got old. And let’s face it, the sequels after the first movie would probably be awful.
    I know this might sound a bit cliche, but a Slender movie would be interesting. However, it wouldn’t be Slenderman wandering around the woods and kidnapping children, it could be how Slenderman got to be Slenderman. Was he an experiment? A human who just had some bad things happen to him?

  110. I feel there should be a jeff the killer movie. With that kid from Hugo playing jeff. thats just my opinion. You don’t have to agree with me.

  111. i think we should make a movie about ben drownded
    here is my idea of the movie
    BEN DROWNDED
    ONCE UPON A TIME,A GIRL WAS PLAYING ZELDA.SHE LOVED THAT GAME VERY MUCH AND LOVED DEAFEATING THE VILLIANS IN THE GAME. THEN ONE DAY WHILE SHE HAD HER FRIENDS OVER FOR A SLEEP OVER SINCE IT WAS HER MOTHERFUCKER BIRTHDAY,THEY DECIDED TO PLAY ZELDA ALL NIGHT.WHILE THEY WERE PLAYING.WEIRD THINGS BEGIN HAPPENING IN THE GAME.[YOU KNOW WHAT I MEAN,RIGHT?]LIKE WHEN ZELDA TRIED TO HEAL THE CARPENTER BECAUSE HE WAS PARALIZED.THEN HE SET HIMSELF ON FIRE.[THAT WAS ACTUALLY FUNNY TO ME.]THEN WHEN JUST WHEN THEY TURNED OFF THE GAME,IT TURNED BACK ON.BENS FACE POPPED UP AND HE SAID,
    YOU SHOULNDT HAVE DONE THAT…
    YOUR GONNA DO THE REST OF THE MOVIE TO YOURSELF OK?
    OK?
    OK.
    FUCK YOU
    IF YOU THINK IM STUPID THEN YOU CAN JUST JUMP OFF A MOTHERFUCKER GODAMN CLIFF
    THEN ROB MC DONNALDS

  112. i would like to see on a hill. it would be full of suspense and downright terrifying as that guy is killed in the hhotel. plus lets face it, abandoned churches always scream trouble.

  113. Jeff The Killer! Need his movie!!!!!!! Jeffy Jeffy Jeffy Jeffy Jeffy :D I would make it myself if they don’t make one! I’ll smear his name in MY blood! I LOVE Jeffy :D :D

  114. Don't ask me that

    I think Masky and Hoodie could make pretty good blockbuster hits.Masky’s could be called “The Hidden One” and Hoodie’s could be called “Shadow in the Dark”.Something like that.I just came up with them.I hope those titles sound good.

  115. I think that Jeff should have a movie BUT then the slender man another that have them duke it out on the big screen and let’s hope it’s not a Freddy vs Jason ending cause if so I’ll be soooo pissed

  116. The ones I would love to see in either a movie or short film would be Ben Drowned, Mentality, and Bedtime. (: Hopefully made really well and not too cheesy.
    I would love to see Jeff the Killer or Slenderman in a Freddie, Nightmare on Elm Street or Jason type style. I think that would be neat. :3

  117. I would love to see Jeff the Killer as well as the Rake, Russian Sleep Expiriment, The Melancholy of Herbert Soloman, and maybe The Gun Game as movies.

  118. I would love to see On a Hill parts 1 and 2 in a movie, I could see it going for at least 2 hours and it would just be total intensity and creepiness.

  119. I'm in your room

    What if they made the song and dance man into a movie? I like jeff the killer but still it mite work. If not there is give her hell.

  120. There needs to be a movie based off of The Rake. Either that or Slenderman VS Jeff VS Jane VS The Rake VS Eyeless Jack VS Laughing Jack VS Masky and Hoody VS Candle Ja

  121. I don’t think you could make a pasta into a movie. Unless they do something similar to Monsters Inc., I highly doubt we’ll see one, despite such popularity. I’d much rather see a TV series made by the people who brought us “American Horror Story”. That would be a good show. I wanna see a movie but I highly doubt we will.

  122. Jhon:
    There is this one creepy pasta where a killer records herself murdering her family grusomely (spelled wrong), and then she attempted to re-marry and kill her next husband on tape. The whole thing was very bone chilling, and I think directors would get a kick out of trying to put it on the big screen.

    I remember that one the end was super freaky

  123. I would love to see “The Door” as a movie. It’s a tad lengthy, not as much as other Pasta’s, but it is really worth reading. It’s about a med student with some really freaky stuff goin’ down inside his apartment. By far my favorite Pasta. Another cool one to see would be “The Art of Jacob Emory”.

  124. There is this one creepy pasta where a killer records herself murdering her family grusomely (spelled wrong), and then she attempted to re-marry and kill her next husband on tape. The whole thing was very bone chilling, and I think directors would get a kick out of trying to put it on the big screen.

  125. I think The Melancholy of Herbert Solomon would be a great movie. It’s so in depth that it could be a full feature film. The twist that it was never actually him would be great on the screen.

  126. Probably the woman holding an orange or something. It’s very well descirbed, long and has it’s creepy parts that I perfectly well imagined in my head.

  127. I would WUV to see a Anime or Movie about Alice the Human Sacrifice or The Alice Killings ect. It would be SO cool! Or Jeff the Killer or maybe Slender ORRR Smile Dog again ——> (dear reader u r hear read the next comment plz :D)

  128. RetardedWalrusNarhwal

    Before this becomes a Slendy VS Jeff argument,I’m going to put it out there that Slenderman is not invincible.So answer the damn discussion and kill yourself.
    On another note,J.T.K or Psychosis would make good movies.

  129. i think “The Holders” series would make a good mini series for a channel like SyFy. but can’t think of a good way to make it into a movie although i would really like to see this

  130. It would be cool to see Slenderman and the dissapearence of Ashley Kansas become movies. The Tall Man sucked. Angel would be nice to see in film too, it would be like When A Stranger Calls only more mysterious

  131. I’d like to see an longer version of the Jeff the Killer or The Rake. I feel like they both have pieces of a great horror movie already, so with some better writing (no offense to the authors) I think they could be huge commercial successes.

  132. I think there should be just a bunch of 45 min. Ones. Stuff like slenderman, Jeff the killer, mr. Widemouth, just all the classic creepypastas

  133. Personally, I would love to see a Slendy movie…But if some of our favorite stories were made into movies would they suck like most adaptations or would they be so realistic it will give viewers nightmares?

    There’s a beautiful concept that may never be pulled off perfectly, sad to say. Just look at the Stephen King flicks–some sucked and some were great.

  134. so what about when tey make the “go to sleep” movies the last one could be were a teen who witnessed the murder of his little brother seeks jeff down and the have a bad ass fight scene like a long one though

    1. At least in a mini series anime if not in movie form.
      If not anime then some really damn good animation…
      I’ve seen some of the vids on YouTube but I would love to see true professionals take a crack at the Alice Killings.

    1. Nah, he’s too old for the part. I think someone in their twenties could play Jeff like Logan Lerman. Flashback or prologue story, someone in their mid-teens.

  135. ANYTHING that involves Jeff the Killer….. And what i mean by ANYTHING is no Slenderman and Jeff the killer, The Rake versus Jeff the Killer, Jane the Killer versus Jeff the Killer… etc. Soooo maybe just a simple Jeff the Killer or Beware of Those Who Would Do You Harm all put together in one.

    -Klamodude
    “Fart is just liquid explosive dinosaurs”

  136. why not make one about me I mean I am a lovable character and plus im very scary oh and if you just finished reading this by now YOU WILL HAVE NIGHTMARES OF ME HAHAHA!

  137. why can’t we just adapt all the creepypastas into an anthology show, you know, like ‘The Twilight Zone’?

  138. Jeff the Killer

    Why not make one about me? My story was amazing, and even if just how it is, it would be short, I admit. But as if they added some of my schooling there, before I started killing people. Oh, and one more thing, if you are reading this, you’re next.

  139. No pastas are long enough to be made into a full length film. Not without the director being an asshole and adding in a ton of random shit that makes no sense, possibly a love interest or crossing pastas in a stupid way.

    I don’t want to watch a movie where Jeff is in love with Slenderman and they have to fight the Rake. That is plain stupid.

  140. I think mine would be the “Beaware of Those Who Would Do You Harm” series. Starring Jeff The Killer as himself.

  141. I just want to say that Slenderman and Jeff will NEVER MEET. If they did, it would he terrible. Would Harry Potter ever go visit Chuck Norris just to “team up” with him? No. Because that is ridiculous.

  142. I’d sort of like to see an animation of The Melancholy of Herbert Solomon.. with similar animation as Spirited Away.. anybody?

  143. There is a Slenderman movie in the works, it’s called Entity. It’s by this independent movie company. I forgot the name but the trailer looks good.

  144. SkaryTells The Sleeper-Keeper

    WHO WAZ FONE?????:
    They should make a jeff the killer movie, that will be awesome

    Well I am glad to say that they ARE making a JEFF THE KILLER MOVIE!

    If you don’t believe me, then look up “Jeff the killer movie trailer(fan made) on @www.YouTube.com OMG THIS IS GONNA BE EPIC, I CAN’T WAIT XD!!!!!!!

  145. I have written a full 105-page Slender Man story that I have written as part of a full series of stories that I have labeled “ALWAYS HUNTING”, although it does include other Creepypastas such as Jeff the Killer and The Rake (and a reference to “BEN Drowned”). I wrote it with the intention of showing the Slender Man’s true invincibility as a threat and am hoping to get it published as a book.
    If someone were to make movies for the series that would be absolutely awesome, a great honour. If you want to read some of my Creepypastas, you can find them on my deviantART account or on the Creepypasta Wiki. Note that Thanatophobia will be added to my dA account soon.

  146. Mandy_Juana follow me on twitter you strange fucks

    Almahetiti if it was more exadgerated,& sewers!! it world be awsome if it was exadgerated.

  147. Her Holding an Orange…..would be very good in movie form
    a full length movie of that
    or…..a short series of The Holders

  148. Dear Abby. There would need to be a few changes in the plot, as there are a few “plot holes”, but overall, Dear Abby. Just yes.

  149. I would live to see Psychosis as a movie because it just seems like it would be a great movie and the concept is just amazing!

  150. slasher master

    i would have to say jeff the killer (and before any one complains i mean many jeff the killer stories since the original jeff story was how he became a killer, maybe it should be about his origin and another person being drivin to insanity by him, like jane the killer)

  151. The Rake, hands down. To me, the Rake has always been the thing that goes bump in the night. I used to have dreams so similar to what happens in that story. The inhuman creature that watches us all, that heralds our demise. It’s so terrifying and exhilarating to think of that being represented as a movie.

  152. Jane The Killer

    I think that Jane the Killer Vs Jack the Killer would be a very great movie, or just the Jack the Killer series.

  153. Definetly Slender, because it would make an awesome story. After watching the playthrough of The Arrival, I believe that it would be the best horror movie made. The movie would be called Slender: The Beginning.

  154. whowascellulardevice

    You could make bedtime into a great movie!¡!¡!¡!¡!¡!¡!¡!¡!¡!¡!¡!¡!¡!¡!¡!¡!¡!¡!¡!¡!¡!¡!¡!¡!¡!¡!¡!¡!¡!¡!¡!¡!¡!¡!¡!¡!¡!¡!¡!¡!¡!¡!¡!¡!¡!¡!¡!¡!¡!¡!¡!¡!¡!¡!¡!¡!¡!¡

  155. creepypasta fan

    Slenderman, because the story is well thought out and it would be easier to make a movie out of it.

  156. NoEnd House. It would be perfect. A full-length movie or a short film would work. I really wish it would happen. owo

  157. Hmmmmm… ALL OV THEM! EVERY SINGLE ONE! Even if i dont know it! Slenders already a movie. U SHOULD WATCH IT! Its on utube. I watched the whole thing this morning!=3 russian sleep expirment would B good, yes. Ooooh! Howbout eyeless jack!=3

  158. The Story of her holding an orange would be a really scary movie!
    The story kept me from sleeping for ages and at night i was scared to look at my window

  159. Probably not stories so much as concepts and characters, like slenderman and ickbarr. They give the writer more freedom with which to work.

  160. I think “the story of her holding an orange” would be a good movie. But first all the other parts would have to come out before I jump to conclusions.

  161. I’d love to see a Jeff the Killer movie! Jeff’s my FAVORITE!! :D
    Though of course you’d need someone to act the part, and they would have to be like REALLY GOOD at acting crazy…hmm…
    Imagine a BEN DROWNED movie!

  162. Though it sounds drool and obvious, Jeff would make for a very interesting movie. The plot could very with either Jane being the protagonist or Jeff or a random unknown character being stalked by Jeff. I think the Tim Burton team would do well with this ( Danny Elfman, Tim Burton, and Johney Depp), and maybe M. Nightshyamalan could help.

  163. I would either like to see “Slenderman” or “Jeff the Killer” as a movie. It would definetley be a “Must See”!

  164. I would like a movie about Zalgo,the smiling dog,the smiling cat and Jane the killer (but don’t make her a lesbian ok? unlike that dumbass in deviantart that makes pictures of her doing it with another girl,etc,etc,etc.)

  165. Easy! I want to see the single greatest story on here made into a movie, and it’ll be called; “Who was movie?!”

  166. ‘Hell At High Altitude’. Really good story, and io feel like it could be dragged out as an animation film or something.

    Also ‘Button Day’ is awesome, would make a very cool short movie.

  167. The Indigo Village.
    The interview situation and the mental home aspect, as well as near death experience thrown in for good measure, all make really good aspects for films.

  168. I dont know about you guys but the one I think whould have been great to have as a movie is jeff the killer :/ Great story

  169. Jackson the ripper

    I would like to see Jeff the killer as a full length, with Mr. Widemouth and squidwards suicide as short films.

  170. there’s too many to choose!!! But what I think will get public attention is probably Jeff.. since he’s famous and maybe one of those “The Holders” stuffs.. I’ve always loved them..

  171. Murderous Dolls R' Us

    The Russian Sleep Experiment all the way. You know, without the plotholes concerning the one extra person at the end. And also Dear Abbey, that would be a creepy movie. Or, the best idea yet, take a whole bunch of creepypasta and make a movie with one after the other.

  172. I would love to see Jeff the killer in a horror movie. Jeff is badass and would be perfect if they made a movie based on Jeff the killer.:D

  173. I would def. say that the rake would be good turned into a movie. There are so many things you could do with the rake.

  174. I think that the Rake could make an interesting horror movie villain, if done right. Jeff the Killer seems too similar to older slasher films, and I would imagine that his similarity to the Joker wouldn’t be lost on people, either.

  175. I liked the Rake. Candle Cove would also be a choice but I think the best one would be THE DAY OF ALL THE BLOOD. It’s kind of a humerous story

  176. jeff da killer would prob b da best movie. im very much into creepypastas. jeff da killer is ma all time fav!!!!!!

  177. Jeff The Killer, and Humper Monkey’s Ghost Story would make really good movies. They’re so well written and it would be easy to make a movie of ’em.

  178. Slendy is already a feared creature to most people, so making a movie out of it would be so flipp’n awesome!!! Cuz I’m a big fan of both CreepyPasta and horror movies! :-) :-) :-)

  179. I think Slenderman and Jeff the killer would both make great movies, also, I’m pretty sure that they are making a Slendy movie with Steven Spillsburg derecting it. (please don’t mind my spelling) :P

  180. They should make the movie “In The Shower” starring Nicholas Cage and for the end credits they should put all the comments they did on the pasta

  181. Even though most everyone is saying Jeff the Killer, I would like to disagree. I think Hollywood would just ruin his story ultimately. Like Slenderman, to me it would just be a waste. Slenderman already has his own game, three actually.

    Other wise, Candle Cove might be good as like one of the stories it would make sense to seem like a fake documentary or possibly Happy Appy, too. I’m not saying I like those the most, but they just seem like they would fit better.

    ~Noodles

  182. Idea!

    How about a group Slenderman has corrupted, and they leave Slendy’s marks so he can see targets, and they, instead of killing each other or Slendy killing them, they get away with it… in a way.

    Sorry about the “in a way” part, I’m just so tired of all the BS about the monster killing those who summon it or they end up killing each other for nothing. Just seems a little unrealistic to have the good guys win over and over and over again.

    If I sound like a sadist… Good.

  183. I personally don’t think any of these should be turned into movies just because I think it would take the creepiness out of it. I mean, you’re at home and you’re in the dark, on your computer reading these pastas and it creeps you out, and makes you paranoid until you can’t sleep anymore, but if they made any of these a movie, I think it would take the whole effect away. But if any of them HAD to be made a movie, I think it would be one on Slenderman and the title would just be SLENDERMAN so there wouldn’t be any guessing of what it’s about, Jeff the Killer would be BETTER than Friday the 13th, and Smile Dog would be awesome it’d be like one of those things going around that no one believes until they see it, like The Ring.

  184. thatguywiththebeanie

    Squidward’s Suicide: A movie depicting not the story but the person who wrote it. How he slowely grows in insane of curiosity and goes on a quest to find out where they put it.

  185. the one out your window

    the warning. that is one of my favorite stories. if you don’t know this one it is about people finding tapes and they explain a serial killer.

  186. I think the “Blind Man’s Favor” would be cool. obviously alot would be open to imagination because its a short pasta. And also, WHO WAS PHONE!!!!!!!!!1

  187. In my opinion, with some work, Happy Puppet Syndrome could very well be interesting. Not exactly horror, but suspenseful.
    I can imagine the ending with the main character hearing laughter, then black.

  188. Jeff The Killer would be good as a movie.
    I think Candle Cove should be a real show xDD
    No End House would be good as a short film.
    Happy Puppet Syndrome as a short film.
    BEN should be a movie.

  189. Would love to see the Jeff The Killer Pasta as a movie. It’s a great story, plus the picture is possibly the scariest thing I’ve ever seen. :P

  190. Instead of just one creepy pasta turned into an movie, it would be better if it was an movie with many creepy patsas, beacuse there is so many creepy pastas that must be longer to make only one movie, but with more it would be pretty scary!

  191. I would like to see either Jeff, or the Russian sleep experiment. Both where really detailed and very creepy. I think that if they where made into a film, they would both be very interesting and creepy.
    (Also, people would really like to see movies from Creepy pasta, so it wouldn’t be suprising if they actually made one)

  192. I wanna see the holders put into a movie, the suspense before walking into each room would be perfect then the gruesome detailing of what the holders look like is perfect, and show what happens when all the peices are brought together :)

  193. The Thing That Stalks the Fields, and obviously, Jeff the Killer. I’m not sure if Slenderman would make a very good movie. It would have to be done perfectly in order for it to work.

  194. Oh man. I am getting a lot of good recommendation for stories to read from this discussion.
    Also, fun fact, Jeff has been mentioned 13 times on this page alone.

    Personally, I would pay money to see “Dust” made into a short film. I feel like it’s already very cinematic, although you’d need a budget for the horses and the CGI near the end.
    I think “The Door” would also make for a good short film, although your biggest concern would be the set, which would probably be complicated.
    Finally, “The Art of Jacob Emory”.

    Whether Slenderman would be good or not would depend on the quality of those making the film. It would be just awful if they simply plugged him in as a standard “chasing the pretty teens” monster.

    1. It would be awesome if they made another Paranormal activity sort of thing and add all these guys into it, like Slender and all of that. Cause I don’t think a movie JUST for Slender or Jeff would be very good.

  195. I think jeff would make a great movie but what about and anime series or something cause he looks better as like a cartoon I have never seen Jeff’s style look good on any living person so IRL would be preaty unlikely.

      1. I feel like if he wouldn’t have died, Heath Ledger would’ve made the perfect Jeff. >> Sorry. Just feel he was a really creepy dude as the Joker and that’s what Jeff is lol.

  196. I personally could easily see the Never Ending House being a great movie. There’s so much in that story to elaborate in, and just so much to work with

    1. I Consist Entirely of Lego Bricks.

      NoEnd House, you mean? Maybe only as a short film.
      I just want to know how the hell they’d do the demon-girl-thing.

  197. Heh>uhNMHEnadjndfj….Uh…//uyuyuyu//rrr;”

    Dear Abby would make a nice movie.

    Tulpa would make a great movie.

    Jeff the Killer would make an AWESOME movie! O3O

  198. I think Jeff the Killer or Slenderman should be made into a movie. Also I bet it would be a Stephan King movie, since he makes horror type movies. :3

  199. someone you all have never head of…
    Zee the suicide lover.

    and if you all must know… Jeff the killer IS in her story. he stays in charecter to. like with jeff vs jane. not some petty lover story. which made me very happy.

  200. I cannot remember the name for the life of me.. but it was this story where a little girl made friends with some kind of ghost which kept trying to get her to jump out of windows and juggle with knives… One part, the ghost said “one day, you’ll be ready to be taken down there” while pointing to the woods.
    The little girl moved away but returned to the house 10 years later. The house had been knocked down but went into the woods where the ghost pointed and she came across a graveyard.
    Would LOVE to see that as a movie.

    1. I think you mean the story Mr. Widemouth. I really enjoyed that one too, and I feel it could be made into a film with a kind of dark sense of humour (if done right).

  201. Alexander of the void

    if you people are intelligent you know “Smile dog” is that to make a visual story of… just dont ruin it

  202. I do think a Slenderman movie is well over due, however, I dont think it would be the masterpiece everyone would be expecting. I dont find Slenderman all that scary anymore. He is all over the internet nowadays, in memes, mods for games, and even his own games. He is practically a celebrity now. Adding a movie to that list would just make him even less frightening. I do enjoy all the fan series on youtube for Slendy. I think MH, EMH, and TT do a fantastic job with their videos. Their stories go much deeper than just being a group of friends trying to escape the Slenderman, which is what I feel Hollywood would do to a movie like this. I’m just not for a Slenderman movie like everyone else is.

    1. THEN WHO WAS KNITTED BLANKET

      I completely agree with your argument. I am surprised Slender man isn’t as over used in merchandise as angry birds is.

  203. I’d love to see Jeff the Killer on the big screen. His character goes a lot deeper than just a psycho murderer. Unlike Jason Vorhees or Micheal Myers, you really get to see Jeff’s character progress from an normal kid into a killing machine. I feel that the audience could really conect with Jeff as a person. Rob Zombie could do a fairly well story with Jeff th Killer, at least with the gore factor anyway. However I feel that maybe a new up-in-coming producer could have their chance with this movie.

  204. BUT WHO WAS FONE?

    Who was fone all the way. That shit gave me nightmares for months after I read it, and I can only imagine the horrors of that oh so ominous ring in the background and the slow walk of that frisky teenage boy to hear that girl’s "dad" answer… -Shivers-

  205. I think that the go to sleep thing about Jeff the killer would be really cool as a movie, I also think that the russian sleep expiriment would be cool. And I believe that both of my ideas should be full – length movies.

  206. If I had to choose any creepy pasta to be a movie, I’d want it to be Candle Cove. The idea of it, it’s purely amazing. And from listening to MrCreepyPasta on Youtube, I can definitely say that the other stories revolving around it would make it all the better. There is also plenty of shimmy room to make adjustments, and even add things you might thing would heighten the fright. I’m sure Jeff the Killer would make a good one, but I just feel that this one would make a better one.

    Now, if I were to really think about it. I’d say you could also make the Jeff vs. Jane one a movie. But most likely would have to make a Jeff the Killer movie before you did that. All the same, I feel like there are too many creepypasta that are worthy of horror movie status to really count.

    If anyone would ever desire to actually act upon these whims of the internet, it’d be amazing. We’d all praise you, and or even help. I for one would help in an instant. As long as I’d be able to help from a distance. Anyways, if any of you wanna talk about this. I’m always open, and I’d love to swap ideas ^^

    1. To add onto this, if I remember correctly. There were some people a while ago I saw, that were actually trying to gather the funds to make a Jeff the Killer movie. For all of you diehards out there, so yeah. Might wanna check it out or something. I don’t know if they ever hit the goal, or if it’s even still going on. From what I last saw, they weren’t close at all to the goal. But I’d just thought I’d inform ya guys that it was a possibility to actually have it a movie. If enough people invest.

      1. Another add-on, Thank you to YOU CAN’T HANDLE THE USERNAME! for the topic. And thank you to DerpButt for providing the site. ^^

  207. I think the holders stories would make a good tv show or movie series. A mini-series with a similar premise was made called "the lost room" but i think that the holders stories are worth it. And thanks for this topic cuz i have herd of some stories that i didnt know about that i have to read now.

  208. Personally, I’d like to see Violent Harvest’s "Trick or Treat" made into a movie. However, I don’t think an unabridged version of the pasta would quite work out due to the ending and somewhat vagueness of the piece.

  209. Tulpa was a great one in my opinion. A movie would really be great to portray the feelings and experience of the guy.

  210. Hmm.. I’d like to see The Russian Sleep Experiment as a movie, I dig psychologic thrillers. The sotry gave me goosbumps and even though I’ve read it months ago, it’s still stuck in my head today. The way it’s written and the story itself, simply awesome and terrifying. I’d love to see that yes ;’)

  211. The String Theory. I don’t want it to be really creepy though. I want it to be like eternal sunshine of a spotless mind. Offbeat psychological short indie film. I’d like it to leave me thinking about life just like what the actual pasta did. I like being melancholic. Imagine a guy like Jim Carrey in the film, waking up to strings and wondering where they came from as this (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rqyGDHmo1ok) plays in the background.

  212. I think Jeff the killer would make a great movie, i mean everyone’s seen/read at least one of them, and knows how much you can do with it. Mr.creepypasta even had a theme-song for the story.

  213. I’d Love to see Psychosis,my favourite, as a short.
    Or maybe Kisaragi station from the point of view of the other people on the forum.
    By the way,derpbutt,i had a great idea to improve the site.Instead of just having a top ten list,you could have a link to ALL creepypastas in order of rating(best/worst/most viewed/most commented).That would make it much easier for people to find new reading material.(Plus-It will increase the amount of time people spend on the site ,and hence increase ad revenue.) Cheers and shukriya.

  214. I would like to see another Slender man movie.One where he kills the damned Sparklepyre and the mary sue!(AKA Edward Cullen and Bella Swan)

  215. Daniel Lee Thompson

    i would love to see slender-man as a movie i think it would highten the bar for horror movies the idea of some creature who can streth his limbs and takes children and does what he does to them ((i suspect he eats them)) and kills people is creepy in its self but the way he makes a very dens fog roll in and sarounds his victems in it and how he kills and just the thaought of a "person" with no identafyable features is creepy as well i would be most enthused if slender-man became a horror movie and personaly it would scar the shit out of millions!!!!

    1. I agree. The Russian Sleep Experiment has great potential for a movie. But I fear that Hollywood would botch the movie by adding crappy CGI, like how they did in The Thing prequal last year. John Carpenter’s version was incredible. All the make-up work and puppetiering mechanics were outstanding. I feel that movies should go back to those ways, especialy if they’re going to make the Russian Sleep Experiment into a movie.

  216. I would love to see Psychosis made into a movie. That is currently my favourite Creepy Pasta I have read on this site. The atmosphere alone would be fantastic.

  217. jeff the killer vs meloDIE the lure anywho i know dhe dosnt exist yet but she will once the creepypasta thingy works im trying to write it but my freaking friends are annoying and trying to make them partners and to tell the truth…. i think they should WORK together nut when my idiotic friends means partners they mean dating and there is NO WAY IN HADES IM GOING TO HAVE THEM DATING EWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWW anyways once i gat the story posted i would love it if SOMEONE will view it and rate it and possibly get likes or a movie … or atleast a animation espcially considering i make animations for a living okay im going to shut up now :3

  218. Why not just do short movies of the Really good CreepyPastas, and instead of a Whole 2 hour movie…

    The average Length of an episode of "The Twilight Zone" perhaps?

  219. The Rake might make a good film if it’s done in the style of "Insidious" and "Sinister". And I know this is for movies, but "The Holders" could make a pretty good TV series.

  220. SomeGuyThatDoesntKnowWhatHesDoing

    Phsychosis. And not to be off topic here, but the story penpal. I know its not a creepypasta, but still.

  221. I read a story a while back about someone moving into a new house, and somthing kept turning of the lights. That was, and always is, my favorite creepypasta. It made me happy to sleep in the dark. I would love to see it as a short. If anyone remembers the name, I would love a reminder!

  222. The Art Of Jacob Emory would make an excellent movie, and I would love to see it. The atmosphere, the subject, and the ending are all very creepy and movie-able.

  223. I don’t want to get anybody’s hopes up, but this was pretty well timed with what I’ve got at college! I work in film production and shit, and I’ve literally just been given the task of producing a short film over the next month, deadline around late December.

    I chose to make a short film based on the Creepypasta ‘Trust’, one of my favourites because of it’s awesome twist and it’s cheap feasibility where props/set is concerned. I’m currently in pre-production paperwork and getting props together, but I should be done with the editing towards Christmas! :)

    I’m not making this some shitty, cheap student film. I’ve gone all out with my camera and my tripod and I’m considering getting Steadicam equipment booked, really excited to start actually! I’m aiming the quality of this film to be near-professional otherwise my tutor WILL fucking hurt me. I’ll try and post it on Creepypasta.com!

    A few days ago I set up my channel, CooStudios, because I’ve decided to try and do a kind of ‘series’ on Creepypasta films, they’re all really good ideas.

      1. tl;dr I know, but this is the first page of the script if you’re interested

        ‘TRUST’ – SCRIPT

        EXT. NIGHT, blurred POV shots displaying first person perspective of a ‘kidnapping’, being dragged down an alleyway, blurred speech etcetera.

        INT. UNKNOWN TIME, EXTREME CLOSE UP of Chuck’s eye, closed, as it opens. Panicked movements of the eye, cut to a pan of his arm struggling on the arm chair, as the view reaches his hand struggling under the belt we see a powerbox with wires connected around the chairs.

        MIKE

        Hey! Hey!

        CLOSE UP of Chuck’s reaction expression of shock as he begins to speak, his face calms down thusly.

        CHUCK

        Hey, you know what’s going on here?

        OVER THE SHOULDER shot of Chuck looking to Mike who is struggling in his chair.

        MIKE

        No! I went to sleep and woke up tied to a god damn chair with some asshole in front of me who’s apparently in the same damn situation!

        MID SHOT of Chuck sitting on his chair, trying to lean forward as he sighs and looks around the room.

        CHUCK

        Can you move?

        MIKE

        Just my head, fingers and toes, damn much that can do.

        Establishing shot of the room they are in from one of the corners of the room,

  224. BUT WHO WAS PHONE?!

    I think Jeff the Killer or Russian Sleep Experiment would be an awesome movie and they would be be the whole story in the movie and I would say Slenderman but he doesn’t have a story to how he became Slenderman like Jeff does and Who Was Phone was a good yet short story

  225. I’d love to see "Altimahtei" and everything that happens ater it in a movie. it’s a great plot and the grgrousomeness can only be imagined! ^^

  226. Of course I’d like to see movies about Slendy, Jeff and Ben… But I think I should call something not so popular…
    Well, maybe Zalgo. A movie about a man obsessed by a powerful demon. So sometimes man turns into nasty black thing with horns, red yees, black skin and bleeding mouths all over the body. And then he begins to kill people. Yes, that’s sounds tritely.
    Hmm… So maybe one about Mr. Mix. A maniac in cook suit, whick takes kids away, cooks them and feeds them to their parents. It would be a good body horror-thriller, I think.

  227. Almighty Darkness

    I feel rake should be a movie just rake dies at the end :O MUHAHAAHA or jeff the killer vs slender man or just a jeff the kller movie

  228. As far as I can tell it looks real. When I first found the movie poster I thought it was a joke, until I really looked at it. It looked too professional to be a photoshop, so I went to the website. I was fully expecting to be trolled, but again there was nothing about it that looks like it isn’t serious. So I think it’s for real, or at least I hope it’s real.
    It would be a really nasty prank if they went through all the effort to make it look legitimate just to mess with everyone.

  229. jeff the killer as a longer one he has a strong base for a movie and you can get into detail of the life after the parents are killed and what happens to the brother

  230. jeff the killer as a longer one he has a strong base for a movie and you can get into detail of the life after the parents are killed

      1. (last reply didn’t go to the right place, oh well)

        It looks like a real Slender Man movie as far as I can tell. Or at least I hope it’s real because it would be a really mean prank if they went through the effort of making it look legitimate only to mess with everyone.

        1. It totally is real. I just looked it up on IMDB. And it’s got a story line, characters, and everything. Coming out this year! I’m excited!

  231. mmm, seeing a lot of Jeff the killer requests in this post. It wouldn’t be a bad idea except for the fact that the movie would have a crappy script, due to the lazy original text. But Psychosis/RussianSleep on the other hand…

    1. If Wordfence thinks you’re accessing pages too quickly for a human/trying to access parts of the site you have no business attempting to access, it will give you a temporary IP ban. Continued violations from the same IP earn a permanent ban.

      1. but all im doing is visiting the site 3-4 times a day,and im not trying to access anything i shouldnt, i dont even know how.

  232. That’s a hard choice but I love this idea. I would probably like to see Mr. Widemouth, Smile Dog, Psychosis, The Angel Statue, Up, Candle Cove, The Orchard, The Maze and some others I’ll name later. They are all awesome stories that would make great movies, espicially Up, Psychosis and my faviorite, Smile Dog.

    Great Idea YOU CAN’T HANDLE THE USERNAME!

  233. Jeff the Killer is one of the only Creepypastas that would work as a full length movie, and Slender Man. All of the other ones could just be short films. So I’m going with Jeff the Kill or Slender Man, but I think that Slenderman would be more interesting because it is less of a generic story.

  234. Vincent Price would be an amazing narrator if he was still alive!He has done an insane amount of movies and narrations,and even did that one verse in Thriller for MJ. So we need to ressurect Vincent Price,forget Morgan Freeman ;)

  235. Guys this may sound like a complete joke, but I am serious, I think Ben is in my PC, I went on cleverbot and I asked if it was Ben and it said yes, I don’t know if that can happen, but it did. Please what should I do?

    1. cleverbot just says things that correspond with the type of question thats why it never goes into detail, and cant string a conversation of more than a sentence

  236. I’d really love to see an expanded Götterdämmerung made into a movie. Like, make it seem like a typical war movie, but focusing on Hitler’s private madness, culminating in the story within Götterdämmerung. Or Gateway of the Mind.

  237. I agree whit everybody on Jeff The Killer, but i would say either Thumps, The Thing That Stalks The Fields or Mr. Widemouth. I think they could all be extended enough to become full-length horror movies

  238. HxCDeaththeKidHxC

    I have three or four…. but I cn only think of two right now xD But definitely Mr. Widemouth and Button Day. I know that Button Day really isn’t as popular, but it scared the crap outta me! lol

  239. I love all slenderman stories but he goes beyond creepy pasta already. I would like to see a first person movie for the story of Ben Drowned. the one where he possesses Majoras Mask… that would be intresting. and also i know its not scary but a more drawn out version of the String Theory would be well worth it.

  240. I think a cool discussion topic would be to talk about how you discovered creepypasta. I mean, we all got to this site somehow. Waddya think, Derpbutt?

        1. I think… I’d like to see Kisaragi Station or maybe a full-on movie adaptation of the plot presented in Internet Story. Maybe The Class, too.

          It’s hard to choose, there’s a lot of pastas I really like!

  241. I think that Jeff the killer would make a blockbuster hit because of the whole story and everything. How he becalmed Jeff the killer…his transition the mugging the carving of the smile and just VERYHITNG

  242. I think Jeff the Killer would be a really good one, and have Johnny Depp as Jeff, they would have to edit the story a little bit, but knowing HollyWood, they would probably do that anyways. The reason I think of Depp is because he’s played so many weird roles already that it would fit him perfectly, plus his roll as Willy Wonka sorta reminds me of Jeff haha

  243. I think a good movie adaption would be of dont go into the basement just made slightly longer im not sure which actors though :)

  244. Well, originally I was going to say slenderman, but I read some of the other comments, and I said, "well damn, all of these would make great movies!"

  245. I really think that, My Friend Jeff, Is it? Would make a great movie, You know, the one were Jeff goes into the little girls room a bunch and the dad flips out. That would be Great!

  246. I’m up for anything, so long as it’s more creative than all the Slenderman crap I’m seeing around Creepypasta. FOR THE LOVE OF GOD, ENOUGH WITH THE SLENDERMAN. Shit’s getting old.

  247. Psychosis please.
    It actually means more than the average post on this site. To be honest I just think Jeff the Killer would be too stereotypical. But if not Psychosis then do Russian Sleep Experiment.

  248. I would love to see A Lack of Empathy as a film. It was so well written that it would make a great movie… I would however enjoy it more if it didnt show the dog getting killed. That part made my tummy turn T_T

  249. The Russian Sleep Experiment would make an amazing movie, maybe a few minor tweaks but otherwise perfect you have to read it to understand why (also my website is designed to take the stress of creepypasta until submissions open I’ll send you EVERY post if wanted)

  250. I’d absolutely LOVE to see Slenderman, Jeff the Killer, Candle Cove and even The Clown or The Angels. Jeff the Killer especially, though. It would be a grand twist on today’s Hollywood Horror. I’m surprised that there has not been any talk about bringing the story to the silver screen. It’s popular enough.

  251. Tulpa has the sadistic negativity that would probably leave viewers terrified for weeks, which is why i think this has potential to be an extremely successful horror film.

  252. is the midnight man a creepypasta? i seen videos of it on mr.creepypastas youtube channel. if he is a midnight man movie based around the game would be cool, like 6 people thought try it in a somewhat large house, and he turns out to be real, i think it would be cool and quite creepy with the lights always being out and you never see the midnight man clearly so your imagination does a lot of the work.

  253. I’m really happy to see this post. My boyfriend and I have just decided to start making short creepypasta films, so seeing what people would like to see is a great resource.

    I’ve already started building the monster for the first film.

  254. I Cant for the life of me remember the name of the pasta i read nor can i find it on here but i know i read it here. Its about a man who rides the metro every day and notices a man on the metro in the same seat every day. He decides to stay on the metro with the man to see where he gets off at and the train leads to a station that is in some other demension. And all the other trains lead to other demensions…That wold make a Shweeet movie

  255. "Sacrifice" would be a GREAT one, the rake needs more hipe. and it MUST have David Tennant in it. even if you dont pic sacrifice, INCLUDE DAVID TENNANT!!!!!!!!!!!

  256. Jeff- he is scary I would watch it. pick Jeff. Do it. Do it Dude. You should do it.. DO IT!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  257. also how abbouuuut, u reopen submissions. get one of ur loyal fans to help u read through the submissions pile if ur so "back logged."

    do as u must, to get things done, or things will be done that no one wants done

    1. Really? I just spent the past week and a half planning and then attending a funeral of someone very important to me, is it so unbelievable that maybe I’m not in the correct headspace to read tons of submissions about death right now? I mean, I’m still reading stuff, but it’s been slow going because I just can’t really focus. I’ve tried to make this clear on twitter, not only was I not even AROUND for quite a few days to do anything, this has been hard for me. I really wish it would sink in for you guys that I’m a actual person over here, not just a machine created to please you guys.

      And your response is to threaten me because I’m not going fast enough for you. You are a stellar human being.

      1. I’ll say this. That type of response, cake, does more to make me want to just forget about this site completely than it does to motivate me. If taking time off to deal with personal tragedy is going to result in threats, I don’t think it’s worth it, to be honest.

        1. Just ignore the cake, he obviously has nothing better to do than bash on the owner of this amazing website. He’s probably jealous that he cant have a successful website, so just ignore him Derpbutt.

        2. derpbutt, I’m sorry for your loss, I really am (I’m a bit slow on keeping up with things.) and I have to say from myself, take as much time as you need, even if it’s just a day or a whole year.

          And to let you know this site (and crappy pasta) means a lot to me. I’ve been burnt out with writing and reading for a number of reasons, one of which was a lack of support from anyone when I wrote. However, I started reading the pastas and tried my hand at writing one. Now I want to write more, due to the feedback I got from both Crappy Pasta and Creepy Pasta.

          You’ve made a difference with at least one person due to this site and for that I can’t thank you enough.

          With love and prayers,
          Don the Bassman

        3. Really sorry for your loss man. I’d like to thank you for creating this awesome website. Stay motivated.

      2. Please excuse people like cake who don’t take the time to read the updates on the front page like the rest of us.

        You take all the time you need. We are all anxious for submissions to be open again, but [most of us] respect all the work you are putting into this site and we’re willing to wait.

        Also, I’m sorry to hear about the funeral. I could only imagine how hard it is to read stories like these while simultaneously grieving over a loved one.

        Please just take your time to heal and ignore idiots like cake. We’ll be here when you’re ready :)

  258. Jeff the killer for sure, its not even a question. theres no other story that has EVER scared me as much as jeff scared me. i didnt sleep AT ALL the first night i heard about jeff. hell, if i dont go to sleep, then i wnt wake up in the middle of the night. i think there should be a contest for the creepiest femal "companion" for jeff. anyone else agree?

  259. im suprised at all of you creepy pasta why has no one suggested "the thing that stalks the fields" it would make a great short movie. a good one hour- thirty minute movie at least.

      1. Actually, if they selected maybe 10-12 of the ‘best’ Holder pastas and made a TV mini-series about them – maybe each episode from the viewpoint of a different person searching for the Holders for different reasons – I think it could be pretty awesome.

  260. The Haunted Cartridge, along with the BEN/Jadusable ARG.

    Except, you know, don’t put it on hiatus halfway through the movie.

  261. I think Jeff The Killer would do an amazing movie, it fits y’know? Like, I don’t think it would be really scary (Jeff doesn’t scary me at all) but it would be really cool

  262. Slenderman or Jeff the killer for sure. There both very popular characters and many people would love to see a movie about them together working as a team.

  263. Isn’t it obvious which ones should be made into movies?
    1. Slenderman.
    2. The Rake.
    3. You could probably turn Psychosis into a movie if you tweaked the story to make it longer.
    That will be all. Ooh, wait, instead of saying "that will be all", I’ll sign off by saying this, my favorite quote from a really cool guy:
    "Stay beautiful, because ugly people suck."
    [Burnsy, you’re so awesome lol]

  264. Psychosis has to be the one. A short film would work, but Psychosis was good because of the build-up. Let’s slow his descent into madness to about an hour long movie. It’s perfect.

  265. I would love to see Bedtime,Mr. Widemouth, of course slenderman, and there was one with a screaming girl in the mans dreams and the girl was dancing to a sond and she was spinning instead of dancing, maybe even Dear Abby too

    1. Awww yeah. I could totally see him in the role. You’d want to sympathize with him at first, but then he’d also make an excellent psycho.

    1. Oh, wouldn’t that be cool? I think it’d be hard to get the true descriptions of some of the rooms and people, I can think of a few that would need some major special effects and CGI. Besides, the Holders doesn’t really have an ‘ending’. It just goes through the motions of how to get the artifacts, not what to do with them, and it never specifies exactly what would happen when they come together. Still, though, a little creative story telling and editing, and even that could come out kind of neat

      1. Freddie vs Jason/ Alien vs Predator much?
        Seriously, crossovers usually suck. It’s just fan pleasing.
        I mean, are we to believe that some extraterrestrial tentacle child molester and some weird skeletal thing both belong in the same reality?
        It’s rare you’d see ONE of those things, nevermind two.
        Also, why would they neccessarilly fight each other? Sure, they’re different species and shit, but two bad guys meeting doesn’t mean they’re automatically gonna fight.

        Hollwood would completely butcher any creepypasta character, by giving them shitty backstories about how they were once humans who were molested by their fathers, or a chemical experiment gone wrong, or the result of some dude jacking off into a radioactive test tube from hell.
        Who the hell really cares.

        By the way, Candle Cove as a film would kick ass. I mean the real candle cove, before they explained that it was just another “lost episode” thing with a crazy director and fucked up actors.

    1. YES!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  266. seccond best rated one, BEDTIME! it would make an awsome movie! (especially if you make it wen the bed shakes over and over again its sped up thru the nights

  267. Definately the one about Jeff the killer b/c it is really the most scary although I cant remember what the title was I got so scared.

  268. I’d love to see The Strangers as a short film, I think that would work really well if it was done properly. I’d also like to see The Salesman, Bedtime and Dear Abby.

  269. Why does everyone want Jeff the Killer? Unless I only saw a really shitty version of the story or something, I’m pretty sure that story was just idiotic (though the picture is pretty great).
    Russian sleep test has potential for movie-ing…especially with more subjects and a better ending…there’s just so much you can do with that one

    1. Bro, freaky fred was one of the creepiest episodes of ANYTHING I ever saw, and it was in a KIDS’ show.
      Way to bring up some traumatizing memories…

    1. HEY JEFF! Did u tell slendy 2 stalk mii? Can u tell him that i luv him even though hes 1000000000 yearz older than me? Plz?plz? Plz?plz? PLLLLLLLZZZZZ??? Hes the cutesed daemon in the world! Can u ask him 2 make mii have shape shifting deamon powerz like him! We can work 2gether! *sigh* thats my dream!=3 hes the best! I watchd hiz intier movie this morning! It wuz AWESOME!=3 OH! And i would absulutly LOVE 2 see a movie about u!!! =3

  270. JoshAtTheEndOfTheStreeet

    Slenderman, The rake, Jeff the killer, Pokemon: Blood editon (As a game)

    I will like to see All these Movies + Pokemon : Blood Editon As a game.

  271. Since we already have a Candlejack Freakazoid episode, I guess a Slenderman or a Jeff the Killer, Oh Wait! Or a Tails Doll short! (but the first two should be full-length movies)

    1. hey man how did you say candlejack and still finish the sentence? wait…. you must be candle jack! cause you finished the sente-

  272. I would hate to see Hollywood sugarcoat my archive of personal favorites, but I suppose…

    Storm-Weathered and Fear-Worn- starring kids that can actually act

    THE WATCHERS- just to have Gilbert Gottfried narrate it

    BUT WHO WAS PHONE- starring Liam Neeson because all roles that involve talking into phones and threatening people just need to go to him

    Psychosis- starring Jack Nicholson, an actual crazy guy

    Ickbarr Biggelstein- starring Seth MacFarlane reprising his role as ‘Ted’

    DAY OF ALL THE BLOOD- basically every Quentin Tarantino film

    Slenderman- starring Barney Stinson

    … yea really just the first one.

  273. Dream Analysis would be a great one because it would be like a murder movie and horror movie all in one and would be a good combination.

  274. White with Red, it would probably be super short but it could be amazing.
    Also The Trap.
    Or a longer one could be Psychosis or The Russian Sleep Experiment.

  275. If God’s mouth had more characters it would make a great movie. Unfortunately it’s hard to make one of those characters die one by one movies when you only start with two.

  276. Kisaragi Station…

    You could have the comments narrated in the background, with Hasumi being a shadowy person.

    zhttp://s22568.p321.sites.pressdns.com/kisaragi-station/

  277. I’m not the least bit ashamed to say I’ve been practicing computer animation by trying to make a Mr. Widemouth short cartoon. And I thnk we all know what this comments section will be spammed with: marble hornets did such a good job, we should be seeing a Slenderman movie soon.

    1. Not as an animation though, I’d prefer if it was a movie. A full length horror movie of Slenderman. If it is a horror animation though, well at least it should be a full length horror animation film, not a short horror animation film.

      1. If it was animated it could also be by Tim Burton. I love his style. The scene on Corpse Bride when Victor is running through the woods with his long stick legs… yeah. That would be great for Slender…

    2. Actually, an indie Slenderman film was made. I haven’t seen it, but it’s called "Wendigo". Not sure why though… Completely different monster. you can watch the full film on youtube

  278. I’d love to see Jeff the Killer become a movie. But since there are already so many murderer movies already, I think I’d rather see someone make a Squidward’s Suicide Spongebob Episode.

    1. Murderous Dolls R' Us

      They already have a Squidward’s Suicide on Youtube. It’s called Red Mist, but it isn’t very good

  279. Damn. Hard decision. Mr. Widemouth would make a good short movie. And Secret Faith of the Spiders would make a great long movie. Especially loved that one.

  280. I think some of The Slenderman stories could be made into a movie quite well. I would have Kristen Stewart playing the Slenderman’s victim because she is such a useless actress. I would also cast myself (hope I don’t sound too big headed) as The Slenderman’s accomplice – I know in the creepypastas he doesn’t have an accomplice but I have read a load of fanfic where he does and it works quite well!

    1. A while ago I started a slender-man movie script and it started off with two brothers running and playing in the forest and one of the brothers ran the other way and went deeper into the forest and he runs into slenderman. Then that kid gets killed and the other kid (his name is eric) sees the slenderman killing his brother,Then it goes to what eric saw,Then he tells them the description of slender-man, Then it goes to when eric is 16 and its wouldve been his brother’s birthday then Eric decides to investigate in that forest and nobody believes him and things keep happening. I am still writing this movie.

  281. Steven Spielberg

    The Mummified Head is wide open with opportunity. You could enhance the movie industry with a masterpiece such as that. If anyone has any screenplay for it, I will feature you as co-producer and director with me. This is a BIG money opportunity.

    1. Think about a situation in which one must end ones own life in order to gain true knowledge and power. I think there actually could be a movie somewhere in there lol.

  282. I would really like to see a rake movie. Or maybe Candle Cove. And of course, who doesn’t want a Slenderman Movie?

    1. I think they already have done an slenderman movie. I think its called “vindigo” or something like that. Also “the blair witch project” is based on slenderman.

      1. They have a movie called “The Slenderman” that’s basically a Paranormal Activity style movie. It kinda sucks though.

    2. I think there’s some movie called “The Entity” based on the Slenderman mythos in the works… don’t know when it’ll come out tho..

      1. I actually saw the trailer, doesn’t look too good. No doubt it’ll end like most horror movies, where the guy and girl meet, both are connected to the antagonist. Then they “fall in love” or whatever and manage to kill the bad guy in some retarded way. Everyone dies but them and they go skipping off into the sunset.

    1. the day of all the blood…narrated by morgan freeman.
      although i dont think he can speak in caps lock, so samuel l. jackson might be more appropriate.

  283. For me, it’d have to be Tulpa, but only if they don’t make it all cheesy and weird and stick to the original feel of the story.
    Also the Lemon-blossom Girl over from Ichor Falls could be a good sort of mystery- horror-thriller but it’d have to be a short film or it might drag a bit, I might make it myself :P

      1. I was thinking this, but I did some research and apparently it’s a pretty heavily used idea. Not that specific scenario per se, but pretty similar. Still love that story though.

  284. YOU CAN'T HANDLE THE USERNAME!

    The Expressionless. Played by Kristen Stuart. Lolololl.
    No but seriously, Mr. Widemouth of the Woman In the Oven would be amazing.

    1. I see you’re a “This Man” fan. Haha, I was gonna say I think that that pasta would make a good psychological thriller if more investigation was done.

      Btw, he intrigues me. Kinda like an incubus is what he seems like to me.

      1. YOU CAN'T HANDLE THE USERNAME!

        Yes A TMF (This Man Fan) indeed! And in fact you’ll be happy to know a horror movie about This Man is being produced! Check it up on wikipedia! Produced by Sam Raimi.

  285. I think that Psychosis would make an excellent short film or one-hour movie. It has some serious potential to be either extremely well produced and amazing, or terrible.

    1. I don’t know. The man’s writing is the most important part of the pasta in my opinion, even if they used a voice over, I still think it wouldn’t work.

    2. Yeah i was thinking psychosis would be a good movie but they would need to add on a little to make it like an hour and a half or so like give a backstory to the man and so on.

  286. I’d vote for The Strangers (I believe it’s called), about the man who gets tricked into riding an infinite inter dimensional subway system. That was an amazing read and, in my opinion, would make a great movie

    1. yeah but the ending would be awsome but what about what hollywood might do to it thats why jeff or slender man might make a better movie

  287. Come on, it’s creepypasta, a short film is the ideal here! Some of the creepiest films I’ve seen have been short ones.

  288. Jeff the killer is perfect for a full length horror movie.. especially because he becomes a badass psycho killer! Let Hollywood choose the actors but i would really love to see it on screen..

    1. i agree with you. i would love to see jeff the killer on thee big screen. it should be about like how it all started at the beginning and then going into other things.

        1. You can imagin the title cant you?

          “GO TO SLEEP”

          Jeff the killer played by heath ledger..oh wait

        2. That would be the best movie ever i can see it right now “Go To Sleep” Jack the Killer played by heath ledger that would be a big sell

      1. i agree. With all the stories about jeff i think it could go as far as a mini series… Possiblly. you know with Jeff vs. Slenderman,Jeff vs. Jane the killer it all seems like real good idea on paper but then again hollywood has a way of changing things.

        1. I'm in your room

          Jeff the killer is a great story so it will be a great one (go to sleep) 1 great line and a scary as crap

        2. I'm in your room

          Jeff the killer is a great story so it will be a great one (go to sleep) is 1 scary as crap line and his face is horrific.

    2. If they make a Jeff the Killer I think I’ll die and go to haven! He’s my favorite and (might I add) One of the sexiest Killer there ever was. <3

      1. I hope its the kind of jeff that’s hot, not the gross version of him but YES. A JEFF THE ,KILLER MOVIE WOULD MAKE THE WORLD.

    3. a movie would be great but what about an anime series depicting his life from the begining and taking ever single pasta about him a seprate episode or multi part episode for longer ones like jeff vs jane

      1. heath ledger would be ideal for that movie. he plays such a good sinister role only when jeff started killing he was 13 plus heath ledger commited suicide. he was the only reason i watched batman. rest in peace

    4. Kinda just wondering, I’m trying to be polite, but is anyone a little tired of Jeff? Like, he’s cool and all, but there are some really amazing pastas out there… I just don’t understand all the fuss.

    5. Im thinking of making a Jeff The Killer movie, i have a Red One camera, i have a great story so why shouldnt i make this movie?
      If you would like to appear in the credits of one of my movies you can send me short stories,((im gonna make 12 short stories per year, and 1 long story per year.)
      Contact me: [email protected]

    1. The Russian Sleep Experiment would make such a good movie but theres one that’s slightly similar to it already made into a movie but still a great idea!!

    2. I agree, The Russian Sleep experiment has an awesome storyline, and a clear ending; it would be perfect for the big screen!

    3. that would be a great fantastic idea but from what viewpoint like would it be from one of the researchers or would it be told from one of the subjects or it could be like you just see everything happen

      1. Im thinking of making a Jeff The Killer movie, i have a Red One camera, i have a great story so why shouldnt i make this movie?
        If you would like to appear in the credits of one of my movies you can send me short stories,((im gonna make 12 short stories per year, and 1 long story per year.)
        Contact me: [email protected]

    4. I feel like the Russian Sleep Experiment is one of the better choices. But, for what it’s worth, On a Hill, and Psychosis would also make good movies.

      1. True,they are my best storie!Also,a really touching one is The Note,and even if it isnt as creepy as the others,i had a dream like it was a movie and when i awoke up i was really sad that it ended.

  289. I imagine Dust could be made into a movie quite easily… It is so well written, it just feels like it could be adapted really well with very little change.

    Others however, like Candle Cove… Those would probably be a lot harder without changing the basic idea of the whole thing.

    Whichever, though, I’d prefer short film. Those are the best at driving something home, and leaving a lasting impression. At least that’s my opinion.

      1. DirkStrider AloisTrancy Katery

        i agree. maybe like short films but about all the creepypastas. that would probably suit everybody because than even the fangirls will be happy

    1. i would like to see all the jeff the killer series to be turned into a movie due to the fact that the only reason i discovered you through it.

        1. if your talking about a fight slender man would win cuz he’s yah know invincible and jeff isn’t so no but if like your being friendly and they’re a team then maybe i like the idea but its a no go sorry :(

        2. Ya I like that idea slender could find Jeff walking around in a forest looking for a cabin the they find one the girl wakes up sees Jeff then sees slendy and then she passes out

        3. actually there’s already a movie about slendermanit’s called always watching but they dont have one with jeff sadly..

        4. I saw a title of a movie about Jeff, I think. It was in Popcorn Time. Anyways I prefer it as a story than a movie…

        1. I would have that movie….I would love that movie…I would be enjoying that movie…

        1. Your totally right!!!!! Hahahahaha :) I think I laughed to hard so hard that I have a headache :)

      1. ya it could be jeff 1 would be jeffs origin then jeff 2 could be about jane the killer then in 3 they could fight but i also would like to slender man since every one is talking about him and iv also have another idea how about slender vs. jason i mean like i would say slender vs. jeff but we would know who won cuz jeff can be fiscaly harmed but like slendey and jason can only be spiraly harmed so who the fuck would win?

        1. She-Who-Must-Not-Be-Named

          Please learn to speak English, and then come back. Or I can just throw a dictionary at your face, whichever one you prefer.

        2. Jeff’s origin is only about 26 minutes long. I think there should be a Creepy Pasta show on SyFy that would have 45 minute episodes. This way, you wouldn’t have to find 2 hours worth of short stories to turn into a movie.

      2. jeff you forget the story of jeff the killer is how he becomes a killer.. Maybe if the maker if this creepypasta makes another we can make it into a movie

      1. I agree and I think the one when the guy marries that girl that ends up being crazy and killed her former husband and kids while recording it on her computer in the basement :-) would make a great suspense/horror film regardless of how many films have been made similar to it

        1. I think Jeff Be careful of who you harm series would be pretty good as a movie because of how long they are all together

      1. If they fix Sonic.exe so it was a little more believe-able and a bit more frightening then yeah it should be a movie.

    2. I’d say Slenderman and Jeff the Killer could make good full movies if they start the basics of the beginning for Jeff and do something like they did with Dark Skies for Slendy

    3. the_cosmic_kitten

      I personally would love to see Jeff The Killer and Slenderman in a movie together!! Seriously! Just imagine it!!

      1. I to would like to see Jeffy and sm in a movie mabie even fight and I think jeff should kill like 100 people before he try’s to kill sm(slenderman)

      2. No just imagine it slender impales jeff than jeff pulls himself off a branch and lights the forest on fire than slendys proxies that would be EEEEPPPPPPPIIIIIIICCCCCCC I find the proxies really cool

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top