Arthur

Arthur

Arthur: story facts
Published on Creepypasta.com November 2008
Length 387 words · about 2 minutes to read
Story level Micro
Reader rating 7.2/10 from 376 votes
Category Deaths, Murders, and Disappearances
2 minute readQuick Read













Rating: 7.22/10. From 376 votes.
Vote breakdown
  1. 10126 (33.5%)
  2. 948 (12.8%)
  3. 853 (14.1%)
  4. 731 (8.2%)
  5. 624 (6.4%)
  6. 516 (4.3%)
  7. 412 (3.2%)
  8. 317 (4.5%)
  9. 211 (2.9%)
  10. 138 (10.1%)
How scary was it?

You volunteer at the mental health clinic. Given the dangerous nature of the residents, they assigned you the rooms of the less violent patients. The suicidal. Those who hear voices. Those that don’t say anything at all.

You become close to a mute man named Arthur. He is a rapt listener, willing to nod his head for hours as you tell him the story of your life. You mention your past, your present. The people involved in both. Your hopes for the future.

And Arthur just nods.

After several months of listening, you figure that you owe it to Arthur to get him out of the clinic. He can’t be happy sitting in a room by himself nodding at interns everyday. You talk to the supervisor of the clinic. You argue that he isn’t harming anyone. That he grooms and feeds himself with no problems. That perhaps his condition is a physical aliment.

The day comes when your arguing pays off. The supervisor has agreed to let Arthur go. You rush to his room to tell him the news. “You’re free!” You shout. “Isn’t that great?”

And Arthur just nods.

You write your name and address on a piece of paper. Hand it to him. “I’m going to miss having someone to talk to.” You say. “But now you can write me. I can learn all about you. Like why they were so insistent in having you in here, pal. I had to fight Dr. Thanner everyday to get you out.”

Also read: Never Again

He looks at you and takes the paper. Just nods.

You go home, feeling good about yourself. You brag to everyone you can tell, friends, family, classmates, co-workers, about how you came through for Arthur. You even fall asleep with a smile.

That night, your eyes snap open. Screams, unearthly screams wake you up.

Then you see them. Your mother. Your father. Your friends. Your classmates. Your co-workers. Lying on your floor, their blood soaking into your carpet. Your walls stained with carnage. Their heads bashed in, their eyes missing from their sockets. Everyone you know dead or dying.

You whimper and see a man standing in the doorway.

It’s Arthur, holding the piece of paper you gave him.

Your entire body shaking, you choke out. “Are you here to kill me?”

And Arthur just nods.

Copyright Statement: Unless explicitly stated, all stories published on Creepypasta.com are the property of (and under copyright to) their respective authors, and may not be narrated or performed under any circumstance.

Similar Posts

132 Comments

  1. Well, I had to let the bitch go because that Holder of watchmacallit was killing every other mental patient. Amazing we get a few hundred requests to see the guy. No one makes it out alive.

  2. huh, when it got to the part about him giving his address to arthur i pretty much figured out what would happen.

    pasta not so good this time

  3. I find it amusing that everyone is picking this to shreds of credibility when the post that started this site was “who was phone” Personally I liked it, I think it was quite a cool concept

  4. Holy shit! I kinda expected the last part, but what the hell? Wouldn’t they at least consider that? I mean helloooo, suicidal patients? It was bound to happen.

  5. @22. I was thinking the exact same thing.

    reminds me of this short story called ¨Mr. Loveday’s Little Outing¨, except this one’s…well…not as good lol. but not baad.

  6. Kind of lame. The ending was pretty much clear from miles away and, really, it felt far too unrealistic to take full advantage of the second person style.

  7. @Sentinel 48

    Agreed. It’s just for entertainment. If you are all about plots and stuff, read another pasta that is complete please.

  8. Despite these plot holes being picked apart already, it bears repeating:

    – why would the supervisor let a homicidal maniac go?
    – was the supervisor just that incompetent?
    – why did Arthur suddenly turn violent if he was not before? or, if he was before…
    – what triggered the violence now if he was a “non-dangerous” patient in the asylum?
    – how did all those people fit into a bedroom?
    – how did Arthur find them or even get them to arrive? or…
    – did they show up on their own, and if so, why?
    – how did Arthur find narrator’s house so easily if he is mentally disturbed?
    – how did narrator sleep through the killings?

    Too many plotholes, not enough time. Shame, shame, shame.

  9. At shuriken (#38): It’s not so much that it has to be longer, but that it needs more detail, a more subtle touch, if you will. I do agree there’s merit in making something short and sweet, stories are more shocking that way. However, this story is stuck in the middle. To long to be a good shock, too short to be a creepy story that sticks with you.

  10. You’re not very fit to work in a mental asylum if you can’t respect the patient-staff interaction rules, are you? Giving out your address as well? That’s about as smart as running into a graveyard for safety during a zombie invasion.

    That said, the lack of supernatural in this story was oddly refreshing, even though I am partial to the unexplainable . I agree that the pacing of this story is too fast, and waking up to four dead bodies is illogical. Perhaps have the protagonist walk through the house and find the dead bodies? There seems to be a lack of suspense at the killing part.

  11. It was pretty good but as if agureing with your boss to let a mental paitent would work, espically if hes suicidal too.. :/

  12. Do you know why that’s funny?
    Because my friend and I, we’re bitches. We like to make fun of people, we tease them. There’s this one boy, Arthur. We’ve systematically taken every fault this boy has to heart. At first, he was able to fight back verbally. His insults turned worse and worse until they just became pleas, the pleas became muttering and sniffing, now all Arthur does is nod. He just looks straight ahead and nods.

  13. Hi, I wrote this.

    To be admitted to a mental health clinic, you are given an evaluation. They ask you a serious of questions and you answer them. Arthur was admitted because of the answers he gave on his evaluation indicated a disturbed mind. Simply disturbed. Not violent.

    I quite like the theory that someone posed about the person the story was about being insane.

    But, honestly, this was written for fun on my livejournal project, http://awcreepypasta.livejournal.com

    I appreciate your criticism, everyone.

  14. When did creepypasta have to be long to be good? I think this one’s good, but too long. I feel like it could be scarier if it was shorter.

  15. I like the whole “you” perspective instead of “I” or “he/she”, and I agree with most of the posts on here. Like really, what is the significance of taking everyone you know into one room? if he didn’t mean to wake you up, then why not just kill everyone in separate places? Assuming you would wake up upon hearing the death of your friends/family in your room, or even house, then arthur must have killed them elsewhere, then brought them into your room, which is retarded because why would he do that? just to freak you out? wtf plotholes…

  16. Ok. Ok. Ok.
    Lemme think this through…
    Basically everyone I knew was killed by Mr.ArthurMurderFace. How can that many people fit in my room? My room is quite small…
    :/
    nice pasta nontheless

  17. @15: Hahaa, me too. Now I’m imagining this little cartoon aardvark going around killing people and it’s fucking HILARIOUS. Ahahaa.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *