A Chat Over Dinner

A Chat Over Dinner

A Chat Over Dinner: story facts
Written by Peter L
Published on Creepypasta.com October 2008
Length 325 words · about 1 minute to read
Story level Micro
Reader rating 7.7/10 from 364 votes
Category Beings and Entities
1 minute readQuick Read













Rating: 7.75/10. From 364 votes.
Vote breakdown
  1. 10115 (31.6%)
  2. 976 (20.9%)
  3. 860 (16.5%)
  4. 728 (7.7%)
  5. 621 (5.8%)
  6. 518 (4.9%)
  7. 45 (1.4%)
  8. 312 (3.3%)
  9. 29 (2.5%)
  10. 120 (5.5%)
How scary was it?

If you are the type who eats out regularly, one day a stranger might join you at the table. This stranger will always appear to be of your age and sex, and he (if it is a he) will only appear if you are alone. No matter what style of restaurant it is, he will always be carrying his own plate of food.

After a few seconds, he will look directly at you and say, “You seem like an interesting person. May I know you better?” Say yes, and he will begin to ask you questions about yourself in between bites. These questions will be innocuous enough at first: what your name is, what you do for a living, and so forth, but should you open your mouth to answer, you will be forced to tell the truth, even if you do not consciously know what the truth is. Remain silent, and the stranger will scowl at you, pick up his plate, and leave. You will never see him again. If you do indulge his questions, however, they will grow darker and darker as the food leaves his plate, and it will become harder and harder to resist answering. Do not attempt to leave the table before he does under any circumstances.

When his plate is clean, he will stand up to leave, but not before asking you one last, irresistible question: “What would drive you to take your own life?” You will instantly be aware that you will be able to lie in response to this one question, and I suggest you do, for whatever you describe will come to pass within the week. Those who are canny may use this chat to gain whatever they desire, but know that if the happenstance you name does not drive you to suicide, the stranger will start guessing as to what will. And consider how much he now knows about you.

—
Credited to Peter L.

Copyright Statement: Unless explicitly stated, all stories published on Creepypasta.com are the property of (and under copyright to) their respective authors, and may not be narrated or performed under any circumstance.

Similar Posts

79 Comments

  1. The only right answer is of course “If you gave me 10 million dollars and then killed yourself.”

    What happens if he ordered something better and you steal bites of his when he isn’t looking?

  2. It carries a reward, but I don’t understand how you would obtain anything you desire from conversation with this man.

    1. Because if you say to the man that if you got something you wanted you would take your own life, then you would get the thing you wanted.
      Example: “What would drive you to take your own life?” You could say, “An Xbox 360.” or “A new car and house.”

  3. lol. i ate alone once in my life at mcdonalds…it was so sad T_T. i dont think i have to worry about a stranger comin up to me, its unlikely to happen again:P

  4. I agree with Fund. It’s nice to see one that is actually a somewhat balanced risk vs. reward situation instead of YOU DIE or NOTHING BAD EVER HAPPENS.

  5. Not creepy, but really interesting and definitely well-written. I liked it, despite the non-creepiness. And, Candlejack, sorry to hear about your cli

  6. Better than most pastas about supernatural deals. This pasta offers both pro and con to accepting the contract while many others are overwhelming good, bad or nonsensical. I enjoyed it.

  7. Wait, what? I do this for a living. I am a professional come-sit-at-your-table-and-ask-you-random-questions-about-yourself-while-we-are-eating guy. :( shit.

  8. ummmmmm…note to self,cancel dinner on my mental health day by myself,maybe take the girlfriend out to a movie…

  9. I liked it. It’s similar to a lot of other stories on the site, but the last sentence was a nice touch.

  10. I liked this one. It was something I could easily imagine happening, since I’m not really secretive about myself that much, anyway….

    Though, it wasn’t THAT scary.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *