The Fourth Wish
| Published on Creepypasta.com | November 2008 |
|---|---|
| Length | 675 words · about 3 minutes to read |
| Story level | Short |
| Reader rating | 6.8/10 from 226 votes |
| Category | Madness, Paranoia, and Mental Illness |
You awaken with a high pitched ringing in your ears. Gradually, the sound becomes softer, like the humming from your refrigerator, and eventually, it stops completely. Even after a peaceful night’s rest, your eyes are not ready to open. Your instincts urge you to KEEP THEM CLOSED, but you find no reason not to open them.
The florescent lights blind you as your eyes are adjusting to the brightness. You are in a perfectly square, white room with one door. One door. There is nothing strange about the door, yet you find it strange how the door seems so ordinary. You are now sitting up in your own bed, in an unfamiliar room. You are not surprised. You don’t know why. But you are not surprised. Your gut is telling you to go back to sleep, telling you not to be so curious, telling you not to….. too late. You notice an elderly man, possibly in his late 70’s, sitting in the corner of the room.
He is wearing a cheap brown suit and a pair of sunglasses. There are several pieces of cardboard signs, resting on his lap. He opens his mouth and begins to speak… he makes no sound. After a few moments, his lips stop moving and he grins. He grins. It reminds you of the smile of a mischievous little boy, stealing toys from his siblings. The man lifts up the first sign, it is written by hand. “Hello, my name is Micheal, do not be afraid of me. I will not hurt you.” He continues to smile, showing his decaying teeth. He switches to the second sign. “I will grant you three wishes, if you want them.
Any information I reveal will count as a wish. I will not hurt you.” He waits. You nod your head. He switches to the third sign. “If you use up all three wishes, I will give you another three, but once you start to use the next set of wishes, you will have to give me something… valuable. I will not hurt you.” You immediately want to know, “Tell me why I’m in this room.” Before your lips begin to produce any sound, his mouth begins to move. You notice his crooked yellow teeth. It keeps moving as though he is talking, yet he makes no sound. You feel somewhat frustrated and cheated by the mute man.
Also read: Nighty Night
You get up and walk towards the plain white door. The man gets up, slowly feeling for the corners of the bed, he crawls under it, it is obvious that he cannot see. You approach the door, turn the knob, and open it. After opening the door, you find that the door is still closed, and you are holding a piece of cardboard with your own writing on it. You read it. “You have one wish left, don’t open the door” You check on the old man, he is still under the bed. He is grinning again, this time, the grin stretches across his face. His decaying mouth begins to laugh.
A soundless laugh. You start to realize that the situation is hopeless. You want to go home. You want to wake up and realize that it was all just a dream. You say to the old man, “I wish this was all just a dream and I won’t remember it when I wake up.” How stupid, you notice it only now. You are deaf. You will never notice this, but you used four wishes.
You awaken with a stinging sensation in your eyes. Gradually, the pain becomes less intense, like a wound starting to scab, and eventually, it stops completely. Even after a peaceful night’s rest, your eyes are not ready to open. Your instincts urge you to KEEP THEM CLOSED, but you find no reason not to open them.
Your gut is telling you to go back to sleep, telling you not to be so curious, telling you not to notice the old man with the rotting smile, staring intently at you.
-Brian Chua
Copyright Statement: Unless explicitly stated, all stories published on Creepypasta.com are the property of (and under copyright to) their respective authors, and may not be narrated or performed under any circumstance.

This is a great idea, but I think it could have been executed better. Good work overall.
I didn’t really prefer this one. It made me think too hard… :(
Hey, that’s us on the other side of the door. Would you pleeeease open it?
We have cake.
he shoulda just wished himself out of the room…….duhhhhhhh
the man crawled under the bed to avoid, the ‘creature’ if that’s what it really is, cause he expects the main character to open the door cause he wants to get out.
Yeah, chalk me up on the author’s side for this pasta. It could use some editing (and more paragraph breaks), but I actually think it’s a great example of the succinct, self-contained-event-and-evocative-twist format that separates creepypasta from ordinary short horror. With this and last week’s sentient zombie pasta, I’ve really been enjoying the output here lately.
So it had happened before and he accidentally gave the old man his hearing, and because he couldn’t remember, it happened AGAIN and his sight is about to go to the man too. And then it’ll just keep on going…
I didn’t get anything about this. Why didn’t he just wish for his sences back (it’s obviouse he would’ve figured out that we has blind/deaf)? Why would the old man go under his bead (it seems too out of place and pointless)? Why didn’t he just wish to be at a specific location in the real world (like a supermarket) with all of his sences intact? Either the guy’s stupid or put himself there.
maybe he’s blind to all the other things in the room exept the old man since he seems like he want’s to play with you more so, he can’t just let you deaf and blind so your next set of wishes
But surely by wishing it was all a dream, he negates all the previous actions? So his first two wishes are undone (because things in a dream aren’t real). Similarly, if he made the same wish before, if it was ‘all a dream’, why does he wake up deaf?
MichAEl, damnit. There is no such name as Micheal.
Sigh. ‘You’ are in a cycle. In the last cycle, the old man took your hearing. At the end of the cycle we are reading, he took your sight. By the time he’s done you’ll probably be senseless or dead. Not creepy, not confusing.
Though I like the concept, I think it could have been executed better…formatting was a big thing with me — that giant second paragraph just contributes to the difficulty in figuring out just what is going on in the story.
The twists are interesting and it makes me wonder just how long things will go on…I appreciate that it made me think.
Honestly. You people need to let up on the author a bit. I actually enjoyed the story, poorly written or not. I was entertained and thats honestly all that matters to me. Concept wise: It was okay too (although it reminds me of another pasta)
I agree with the comment mentioning the fact that he should’ve noticed something was up when there was no sound at all. When you walk you make noise.
I wonder how the guy got into this situation in the first place.
By the way why would the old man be sitting in a room with some kind of creature that could potientially harm him next door? and seeing as the guy would be right by the door how did the monster not trash his ass before he got a chance to close it?
it was good.
a little confusing.
i had to read it like, 3 times to understand it, but i liked it=)
since his eyesight is gone how is who was old man going to communicate with him? is he going to make a tasty message? maybe if he lost his other senses first it would be more brix shatting.
good concept but all the extraneous information made it confusing. trim it up and this could be some delicious pasta.
Really a great concept. Most of the people trashing were probably just too stupid to understand it. It could have been written more clearly, but altogether I liked it.
Better than Twilight by stephanie meyer I guess..
hello.
this is nice.
you who don’t get it should be impaled.
maybe he’s mute now.
Chalk me up as one of the non-haters, because to me this was a grand ol’ mini-labyrinth of cyclical narrative. I too am not sure how the protagonist knew about his tormenor at the end…maybe the old man imprints on reality so much that it’s impossible not too notice.
@adsf’s comment, just because you don’t get it doesn’t mean what was written was a mistake.
1) the first time he opened the door, something happened, which is unknown to the reader.
2) the main character must have wished whatever came out of the door away, which explains why when he opened the door, he finds the door still closed.
3) he wrote the sign to himself so that he would not open the door again, and to notify himself that he only has one wish left, because he used his second one.
4) the man had crawled under the bed to protect himself from whatever was behind the door, because he knew the main character would open it because he had done so during his first set of wishes.
5) he realized the man was blind because he had a difficulty getting under the bed, not because he ‘crawled under the bed by mistake.’
however, one criticism is if the main character lost sight after the second set of wishes, he wouldn’t be able to see the man, or ‘notice’ him.
now that I look at it again… there’s a LOT of little things that are easy to miss… and not noticing the little things cripples the entire pasta as a whole. it will be better next time =)
Good story but hard to follow..
Honestly, I’m just happy that creepypasta was updated. Not the best, but decent enough to read.
I liked this one.
How could you all not understand it? He didnt notice he was deaf because he figured the old man was cheating him out of wishes (by “giving information”, but at the same time making sure the guy couldnt use it, I.E. making the room quiet.)
the old guy brought the guy there, and is one by one stealing a sense from him with the wish scam.
Bravo, Brian.
hey that was clever!
wait…
I see hat you did there
I feel an endless paradox in this pasta.
What happens then, after the man removed all of the poor guy’s senses? His skin? Lungs? Heart? Liver?
Blah. Basically I grasp the concept, but it doesn’t scare me. Unless I happen to wake up in a white room with a old man sitting in the corner….
Allie is probably right, actually, that makes sense. Only, the first thing he said, ‘what am I doing in this room’ was the fourth.
The information he gave him counted as wishes.
I don’t think he’s blind when he starts over, it says that he opened his eyes and tried not to notice the old man…