The Fourth Wish

The Fourth Wish

The Fourth Wish: story facts
Published on Creepypasta.com November 2008
Length 675 words · about 3 minutes to read
Story level Short
Reader rating 6.8/10 from 226 votes
Category Madness, Paranoia, and Mental Illness
3 minute readQuick Read













Rating: 6.75/10. From 226 votes.
Vote breakdown
  1. 1060 (26.5%)
  2. 929 (12.8%)
  3. 823 (10.2%)
  4. 727 (11.9%)
  5. 616 (7.1%)
  6. 516 (7.1%)
  7. 411 (4.9%)
  8. 39 (4.0%)
  9. 210 (4.4%)
  10. 125 (11.1%)
How scary was it?

You awaken with a high pitched ringing in your ears. Gradually, the sound becomes softer, like the humming from your refrigerator, and eventually, it stops completely. Even after a peaceful night’s rest, your eyes are not ready to open. Your instincts urge you to KEEP THEM CLOSED, but you find no reason not to open them.

The florescent lights blind you as your eyes are adjusting to the brightness. You are in a perfectly square, white room with one door. One door. There is nothing strange about the door, yet you find it strange how the door seems so ordinary. You are now sitting up in your own bed, in an unfamiliar room. You are not surprised. You don’t know why. But you are not surprised. Your gut is telling you to go back to sleep, telling you not to be so curious, telling you not to….. too late. You notice an elderly man, possibly in his late 70’s, sitting in the corner of the room.

He is wearing a cheap brown suit and a pair of sunglasses. There are several pieces of cardboard signs, resting on his lap. He opens his mouth and begins to speak… he makes no sound. After a few moments, his lips stop moving and he grins. He grins. It reminds you of the smile of a mischievous little boy, stealing toys from his siblings. The man lifts up the first sign, it is written by hand. “Hello, my name is Micheal, do not be afraid of me. I will not hurt you.” He continues to smile, showing his decaying teeth. He switches to the second sign. “I will grant you three wishes, if you want them.

Any information I reveal will count as a wish. I will not hurt you.” He waits. You nod your head. He switches to the third sign. “If you use up all three wishes, I will give you another three, but once you start to use the next set of wishes, you will have to give me something… valuable. I will not hurt you.” You immediately want to know, “Tell me why I’m in this room.” Before your lips begin to produce any sound, his mouth begins to move. You notice his crooked yellow teeth. It keeps moving as though he is talking, yet he makes no sound. You feel somewhat frustrated and cheated by the mute man.

Also read: Nighty Night

You get up and walk towards the plain white door. The man gets up, slowly feeling for the corners of the bed, he crawls under it, it is obvious that he cannot see. You approach the door, turn the knob, and open it. After opening the door, you find that the door is still closed, and you are holding a piece of cardboard with your own writing on it. You read it. “You have one wish left, don’t open the door” You check on the old man, he is still under the bed. He is grinning again, this time, the grin stretches across his face. His decaying mouth begins to laugh.

A soundless laugh. You start to realize that the situation is hopeless. You want to go home. You want to wake up and realize that it was all just a dream. You say to the old man, “I wish this was all just a dream and I won’t remember it when I wake up.” How stupid, you notice it only now. You are deaf. You will never notice this, but you used four wishes.

You awaken with a stinging sensation in your eyes. Gradually, the pain becomes less intense, like a wound starting to scab, and eventually, it stops completely. Even after a peaceful night’s rest, your eyes are not ready to open. Your instincts urge you to KEEP THEM CLOSED, but you find no reason not to open them.

Your gut is telling you to go back to sleep, telling you not to be so curious, telling you not to notice the old man with the rotting smile, staring intently at you.

-Brian Chua

Copyright Statement: Unless explicitly stated, all stories published on Creepypasta.com are the property of (and under copyright to) their respective authors, and may not be narrated or performed under any circumstance.

Similar Posts

128 Comments

  1. holy shit, this was fucking brilliant in every sense of the word

    my new favorite story, hands down. holy fuck. holy shit.

  2. It seems reasonable to assume that whatever is on the other side of the door is what orchestrated the entire situation in the room. I guessing that whatever it was imprisoned the old man and the only way that the man can escape is if he tricks another to take his place. I’m guessing that by the time he’s finished, he will have stolen everything from the narrator, who will then take the man’s place in the room.

    There he will remain, tormented by the thing on the other side of the door, until he can trick another intrepid dreamer into replacing him in the evil room.

    Awesome story, and I think the type that you have to understand almost immediately in order to be scared of it (similar to how a joke is not as funny if someone else has to explain it to you).

  3. It seems reasonable to assume that whatever is on the other side of the door is what orchestrated the entire situation in the room. I guessing that whatever it was imprisoned the old man and the only way that the man can escape is if he tricks another to take his place. I’m guessing that by the time he’s finished, he will have stolen everything from the narrator, who will then take the man’s place in the room.

    There he will remain, tormented by the thing on the other side of the door, until he can trick another intrepid dreamer into replacing him in the evil room.

    Awesome story, and I think the type that you have to understand almost immediately in order to be scared of it (similar to how a joke is not as funny if someone else has to explain it to you).

  4. following up on miktar and dooreatoe, i actually believe that his ‘tell me why…’ wish was his second wish. the ‘omg, cancel my opening the door’ wish was the third one.

    he’d never know this, and the reason why the old guy smiled, was that when he used his third wish (that one sentence counted as one) he was actually using his fourth wish, i.e. his first wish of his next set.

    when he wakes up in the next round, he’ll begin with wish two, set three.

    well thought-out, i’d say.

  5. Really liked this one. Perpetiual evil? Very niiice. n.n Especially liked how the writter touched base on just how much no one ever listened to their gut instincts anymore. It’s what those little feelers are there for. Humanity just might be a doomed species after all.

  6. This is one of the best ones on this whole site. Everyone who said anything about it was poorly written is a fool. Also, Dooreatoe really did do an excellent job explaining it to anyone who might not have gotten it. I find it a spoiler, but obviously so few were smart enough to get it on their own that it was necessary.

  7. Outstanding Pasta,
    Well thought out, relized what was happening as soon as they story wraped up and i loved it.
    Very Reminicent of Stephen King, and great props to the author!
    Keep them Coming!

  8. dont you get it? he wished he would wake up and not remember it, which means he did it once before. losing his hearing and explaining the buzzing then waking up and not remembering it, and this time he lost his eyes.

  9. Foolish mortals! Jack got it right away. Dooreatoe, thank you for explaining it to all the piddley little commoners.

  10. I got it! The reason this is more tricky to understand than other stories is most likely because we aren’t directly told what happens to the second wish, or why he is deaf in the first place. A good horror story always leave room for interpretation.

    Wish one: When he asks in his head why he is there and gets an answer, but doesn’t hear it due to his deafness. He gets extra information that wasn’t readily provided on the cards, so that’s one wish.

    Wish two: When he opened the door, something bad was behind it. We know this because the old man went to hide under the bed. Whatever was behind it must have been wished away. There is a wish gone and he wrote himself a note as a reminder of that, as well as to not open the door again.

    Wishes three and four: All used in one sentence, where he wishes it was all a dream AND he didn’t remember it. This is when he notices he is deaf, because he doesn’t hear his own voice when he says the wishes. The reason he’ll “never know” he used four wishes is because the last wish was to erase his memory. He was deaf before these wishes started. He probably screwed this up before in the exact same way just a second ago, hence not noticing the newfound deafness. We can assume this because he wakes up with a ringing in his ears, similar to waking up with the pain in his eyes at the end. At the beginning, the vague urge to keep his eyes closed is probably due to wishing before that he would have no memory of that situation, so he only is left with an inkling of caution. He wakes up with the same vague feeling at the end of the story. I’m guessing he doesn’t get to “go home” if he uses too many wishes.

    The last paragraph gives you all the info you need. He wakes up with pain in his eyes, “like a wound starting to scab”. Read closely, the person never opens his eyes. He has yet to notice the old man “staring intently”. Don’t you remember, the old man was blind and wearing dark glasses in the white room! He’s no longer blind, and guess why. :)

  11. VERSION FOR PEOPLE THAT AREN’T SMART:”Tell me why I’m in this room.” Seems to be his first wish. The second is a mystery, but involves closing the door, and the kid writes to not repeat the act, meaning that what was behind the door is still there waiting. His third AND fourth wishes are all in one sentence, where he wishes it was a dream, and he won’t remember it WHEN HE WAKES UP. Remember the beginning when he has the urge not to open his eyes? it’s because he’s been through the loop before and remembers enough not to open them, so he will be left alone. Dunno what the guy took last time, but I’d imagine taste or something, something he wouldn’t notice. Whatever hurts before he wakes up seems to be what will be taken away before he inevitably fucks up and gets it taken away by the old man. He still has his sense of hearing when he starts off, or he wouldn’t have the ringing in his ears, nor be able to hear his own answers. Also, the term ‘this’ is relative, allowing the old man to bend it to his will. How he got there in the first place, who gives a fuck, and maybe the hearing was the first of his senses to go, but that wouldn’t explain why his instincts tell him not to open his eyes.
    The rest, feel free to interpret. :P

  12. I did like this pasta.
    Good, good pasta.
    I love the concept of this story- very intriguing, and I believe it is well written.
    I agree with many others- that this was his second set of wishes.
    Kudos.

  13. It was written like shit but the point still got across. I liked it, it reminded me of the old man who used his last wish to know who he was.

  14. Umm…
    It took me a minute or two but, i get it. Could’ve been written better but, it’s really good otherwise. My take on it is that the old man didn’t have any senses so took the kids in this never-ending dream-mabob. I got this from the fact it said “The man gets up, slowly feeling for the corners of the bed, he crawls under it, it is obvious that he cannot see.”
    Therefore in the next dream-mabob he took his sight and, can now see.
    :D
    Lol i’m not very good at explaining, am I? ‘Course there is other points to the story but, you can read other people’s comments for that.
    I liked this story though, because it had an interesting idea. Not uber scary but, not -ALL- pastas are.
    All-in-all, GOOD JOB C:

    ~Peace ‘n Love
    Bagel-chan

  15. Does anyone know where I can find a boyfried-free girl to make into a sweetheart from the ground up? Hold the pickles.

  16. Nice concept, but rather difficult to read. Took me a few reads to get the story straight. I think this would play out better as, say, a comic or a video much better than it would as a story. That way, chronology would be more easily established, and visualization would help it deciphering the harder to understand parts.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *