The Deepest Fear

The Deepest Fear

The Deepest Fear: story facts
Published on Creepypasta.com May 2008
Length 173 words · about 1 minute to read
Story level Micro
Reader rating 5.8/10 from 379 votes
Category Madness, Paranoia, and Mental Illness
1 minute readQuick Read













Rating: 5.79/10. From 379 votes.
Vote breakdown
  1. 1093 (24.5%)
  2. 911 (2.9%)
  3. 830 (7.9%)
  4. 738 (10.0%)
  5. 638 (10.0%)
  6. 525 (6.6%)
  7. 426 (6.9%)
  8. 328 (7.4%)
  9. 230 (7.9%)
  10. 160 (15.8%)
How scary was it?

You’ve been dating your girlfriend almost two years now. You often stay late over the summer and on weekends and arrive home long after the rest of your family go to sleep.

Every night you drive the deserted rural roads back home from a pleasant evening at her house you become overwhelmed by fears that you will arrive home to find your family dead in their beds. Each night you peek into your sister’s room and see she’s fine and hear the reassuring rumble of your father’s snore as you pass your parents door.

You chuckle at your silly worries and drift off to sleep. Finally one morning you decide to tell your mother about your late night fears amidst some jovial conversation for a nice laugh. As you tell her a concerned look comes over her face. She sweeps the hair away from her face as she says, “Oh honey, you know we were all shot almost two years ago.”

You scream as you see the gaping bullet hole in her forehead.

Copyright Statement: Unless explicitly stated, all stories published on Creepypasta.com are the property of (and under copyright to) their respective authors, and may not be narrated or performed under any circumstance.

Similar Posts

44 Comments

  1. Ehh, I didn’t really like it. Dumb ending, and with the whole "You did __" thing, BITCH I KNOW WHAT I DID AND I DID NOT DO THAT XD

  2. Why the bloody hell are most stories second person???!!!!!! I agree with Dreamer. The form that this story was horribly written. It would’ve been better if it was narrarated like the main character was talking about it. And why does it says about his grilfriend in the first place? So here’s to the new and improved story; My deepest fear is that my family would be dead in their bed. Everyday, I come home late. When I come home, everybody would be sleeping. So I check my sister room to see if she’s breathing and I go to my parents room to hear my father’s snoring. That makes me feel foolish. I would chuckle at myself for my worries. Whenever I drive through the road to home, I’m always scared that my family will be dead in their beds. One day, I decided o tell mom. “Mom, you know when I drive through the road to get home? I’m always worried that I’ll find you guys dead.” I thought mom would laugh at this. But instead, she looked concerned. “Sweetie,” mom touched her hair that was covering her forehead, “You know we were all shot almost two years ago.” then mom lifted her bangs to reveal a gaping hole in her forehead where a bullet was stuck in their. I screamed. SO, do you like the new and improved version of this story?

  3. There are two ways that I can see to interpret this pasta:

    The first way hinges upon what his mom says at the end: “You know WE were all shot…” We, including the narrator. In other words, the boy is trapped in his own repeating afterlife. The girlfriend he’s been dating for two years is a manifestation of said afterlife. He continually repeats the night he drove home, found his family dead, and was shot himself.

    The second hinges upon what his mom says at the end, again, but a different part: “…shot almost two years ago.” Notice how he has also been dating his girlfriend for almost two years, and feels fear when he drives home. My second theory, the one I am leaning more towards, is that the boy drove home after visiting his girlfriend and found his entire family dead . Upon discovering their gruesome bodies he went insane and now repeats this every so often in his head. He’s still trapped in his fantasy but very much alive. I imagine he’s in a padded room somewhere, verbally acting out what is replaying in his head, and that perhaps what his mom just told him might be the thing he needs to snap out of his fantasy and start becoming mentally well again. This would have worked better, of course, had his reaction been left up to the reader.

    Mediocre pasta. Should have been either much vaguer (ie omit last line) or much more specific.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *