I’m Not Alone On This Bench
| Written by | Todd Foley |
|---|---|
| Published on Creepypasta.com | November 2026 |
| Length | 579 words · about 3 minutes to read |
| Story level | Short |
| Category | Psychological Horror |
I just got to the carnival. It’s a happy place. A safe place. A place where I know I’m not alone.
I look around, and see a Jester. And a mime. Carousel. Cotton candy. Popcorn.
Joy. The ever present now.
My ears ring from the loud rides, a sound that competes with joyful shouts and cheerful music.
I don’t have any tickets. But even if I did, I’m not tall enough for any of the rides. So I watch.
My legs grow tired, but I don’t see anywhere to sit.
Finally, near an exit gate, I see a bench. It says “Buddy Bench.”
The Jester roams through the crowd. He smiles, big and broad, spreading cheer to everyone willing to hold eye contact. Then he looks at me. We exchange a safe grin.
The music continues. Loudly.
But then, the music slows. Not a decrease in volume, but in speed. Slower, slower, slower.
And so does everything else. The rides. The chit chat.
The Jester stops smiling. He doesn’t look around, because he doesn’t need to know what caused the slowdown, or the reason for it.
Finally, slowly, the Jester looks over at me. His expression doesn’t suggest, “Oh no, what is happening?” Instead, his eyes say, “Oh, no, it’s happening again.”
My small hands start to sweat. I don’t know what to do with the Jester’s expression. I wish he would look away from me.
Every other face at the carnival is now looking at me. They stay still, seemingly wishing they could take a step back.
Are they afraid of me? The boy not tall enough to even enjoy the carousel?
But as I look closer at the Jester, closer at his eyes, they aren’t mirrored right back at me.
Close, but just to my left.
Same as everyone else.
But I am alone on this bench.
Right?
Right.
…right?
I look down at my feet, then turn slightly, just slightly, to my left.
Grass.
Also read: If You’re Armed and at the Glenmont Metro, Please Shoot Me
More grass.
Some gravel.
And then…
…shoes. Brown shoes. The formal kind people wear to church.
But the shoes aren’t just there on their own. They’re being worn.
My eyes go up, just a bit. Dress pants. Grey.
Up a bit more. One hand on the bench, gripping it. Strong hands. Big hands.
Not gentle ones. Not safe ones.
I try to see what he looks like. But I can’t look up. As much as I try.
I don’t want to be here. I want to go home.
The exit gate is just behind me. I should stand up and leave.
But I can’t move.
Is he looking at me?
I can’t see. But I can feel…something. Cold, but also hot.
His hand stops gripping the bench. It moves, slowly. Closer to me.
I don’t know what this feeling is called, but it doesn’t feel right.
I look back to the Jester. He’s not as close. He stepped back. The Jester knows it’s not okay to be here when he is here.
Everyone else moved back too. Some people found something to hide behind.
I look at the cotton candy booth. It isn’t that far away. I could go there. I could hide behind it. Away from that hand that isn’t safe. Then he couldn’t see me, and I wouldn’t feel hot and cold.
But I can’t go there to hide. As much as I want to, I can’t move away.
I’m stuck here.
And I’m not alone on this bench.
Credit: Todd Foley
Please note the author of this Creepypasta does not give permission for it to be reproduced in any other medium
Copyright Statement: Unless explicitly stated, all stories published on Creepypasta.com are the property of (and under copyright to) their respective authors, and may not be narrated or performed under any circumstance.