The Bad Idea
| Published on Creepypasta.com | May 2008 |
|---|---|
| Length | 220 words · about 1 minute to read |
| Story level | Micro |
| Reader rating | 7.7/10 from 416 votes |
| Category | Beings and Entities |
Yesterday, a friend of mine called me. It was a John, an old buddy from high school. I hadn’t spoken with him for years, and we started to reminisce about all the crap we pulled in high school. A few days later I decided to call him back, and see if we could get together, maybe go fishing or something.
We talked on the phone for a while, and I said to him “Hey, maybe we should get together sometime.” He first said that that was a bad idea, but then he agreed. I asked him for address, copied it down, and told him I’d see him in the morning.
The next morning I arrived at the place he said he lived at. There was nothing but rubble there. It looked like there had been a fire there years ago, but nothing got cleaned up, and the plants never regrew. In the middle of the rubble, I found a old rotary style telephone on the floor, not connected to anything. Hurriedly, I pulled out my cellphone and called his number.
The telephone on the floor rang.
Also read: I Am the Apocalypse
Once.
Twice.
A third time.
I dropped my cellphone in shock, and knelt to grab the rotary telephone. A voice, drenched in distortion and hiss, said:
“I told you this was a bad idea.”
Copyright Statement: Unless explicitly stated, all stories published on Creepypasta.com are the property of (and under copyright to) their respective authors, and may not be narrated or performed under any circumstance.

Fucking cliffhangers
wtf but it was good
You know what John? You were right, people should freaking listen to others in these stories…
Step aside Batman, Armless is my new hero
XD
What’s stopping them from having a good time? His friend may be dead, but as long as he’s not spiteful ghost/zombie/demon, I’m pretty sure they can chill.
XD This story was meh, for me. But I like some of the comments people made, they were funny.
Uh… so, narrator picks up phone even though HE is calling, meanwhile a John ghost sneaks behind him, picks up the mobile phone he dropped and answers from there. Laughter ensues.
Sorry but he answering the abandoned phone sounds stupid, wouldn’t it have been better if the phone suddenly stopped ringing and at the same time he heard in HIS phone the answer?
BUT WHAT, WHO WAS BAD IDEA
I love this story, but because as a hobby I ”illegitimately borrow” things from people in the night, I get freaked out as fuck.
One of the few creepypastas that have given me chills so far. Granted I’m a few years late to this awesome site. I’m sure there will be many more chills to come.
It was a John… which one?
John was PHONE the whole time!
it didn’t give me closure I felt like it was missing something
and john wasn’t A phone is soul was talking to him through the phone the phone was on top of where he died and the “who was… ” is stupid it isnt funny everyone does it on here its lame and over played!!!!!
that was on twilight zone same thing but the power-line was on top of a grave stone
BUT WHO WAS RUBBLE
No John you are the phone. And then John was phone.
JOHN IS TRAPPED INSIDE TELEPHONE
Damn, I wasn’t the first to realize that the author was a prostitute.
Also, if I found out that my friend was dead but still talking from beyond the grave or that I was talking to a supernatural entity, I’d probably be okay with it.
It was a John
So the author was a time travelling prostitute?
That’s right, guys. So knock off the bullshit “WHO WAS…” comments. Because you know know JOHN WAS PHONE!
Y’see, fucking High School these days.