Up late with the Abernathys
| Written by | Neil Driscoll |
|---|---|
| Published on Creepypasta.com | November 2026 |
| Length | 3,122 words · about 14 minutes to read |
| Story level | Medium |
| Category | Paranormal |
“That’s it, stop!”
Scott froze, then gingerly took a step back from the television set.
“Now quick, come back. Lila’s about to find Mrs Bates’s corpse,” Janie screeched as she pulled the blanket up to her chin.
Scott dove back onto the sofa and Janie wasted no time snuggling back into him. That had been the fifth time throughout the movie Scott had been forced to fiddle with the flimsy wire antenna. It now took up yet another position on top of the brown-cased television set. They had already missed part of the infamous shower scene and had both cursed Scott’s basement den as the cause of the disruption.
Janie cowered through the final scenes of the movie as Scott finished off the rest of the popcorn, leaving nothing but discarded kernels in the bowl.
“What time are your parents home tomorrow?” Janie asked, even though she knew the answer.
“I told you, they won’t be back until well after lunch, don’t worry,” Scott reassured her for the umpteenth time.
“Oh it’s not me who should be worried,” Janie howled playfully as she flung back the blanket and attacked her boyfriend with a barrage of kisses.
“Come on, let’s go up to bed,” Scott said as he began to lift himself from the sofa.
Janie looked up at him with an almost mischievous grin.
“What is it?” Scott asked, a little wary.
Janie flung one leg under herself and patted the sofa next to her. “Sit back down for a minute. I have an idea.”
“Okay…” Scott said as he cautiously returned to the sofa.
Janie turned in to face him but before she spoke, grabbed a pencil from the coffee table and stuck it through her hair. The bun was a little messy, but it kept any unwanted strands out of her face.
“So, I want to try something.”
Scott furrowed his brow, then broke a half smile as he ran his hand up her thigh. “OK, I like where this is going.”
“Oh behave,” she giggled, and with a playful smile, swatted her boyfriend as though he were a giant fly.
Just a few feet away, the words ‘The End’ appeared on the screen before it faded to black.
“Alright, what’s going on?”
“Have you ever heard of the Abernathys?” she asked, watching his expression closely under the dim light of a nearby standing lamp.
Scott adjusted himself until he found a more comfortable position, but this time he furrowed his brow for real.
“The who?”
“The Abernathys?” Janie replied.
Scott’s expression didn’t change; he just simply shook his head.
“I was talking to Debbie. You know, Debbie Henderson,” Janie began. “Well, she told me…”
“Wait,” Scott cut in, “Debbie with the retarded brother?”
“Yeah, that Debbie,” she continued. “No! I mean yeah, but he’s not retarded. Just a little slow. Anyway, she told me about something strange. A secret show.”
Scott stared at Janie – wondering to himself why they weren’t in bed already – when a voice from the television made them both start.
“This concludes our broadcast day. We thank you for watching and wish you a very pleasant good night.”
Feeling foolish, they returned to their conversation.
“What secret show?” Scott asked.
“Well…” Janie hesitated. “Apparently it’s a 1950s sitcom. It can appear when…”
Janie was once again interrupted as the American national anthem filled the room. They both glanced at the television and saw that the station sign-off announcement had been replaced with a motion picture of the stars and stripes billowing in an unseen wind. They watched on in a semi-daze.
“According to Debbie,” Janie continued, breaking their trance, “if you stay up late and keep your TV on past the station sign-off, you have a chance of finding this hidden show. She heard it from her cousin Josephine. I’m not exactly sure how it works or what it’s called, but I think it was something along the lines of ‘up with the Abernathys’.”
The room grew silent as the national anthem came to an end. All that remained on the screen was the American flag in all its red, white and blue glory.
“Babe, that doesn’t exactly sound like the kind of show I want to stay up for,” admitted Scott. “Come on. Let’s get to bed.”
“No wait,” Janie protested as she grabbed him by the arm. “There’s more. If the show appears, you must be quick to turn it off.”
Scott looked confused. “So you’re saying that if this Arbernaty show comes on, we can’t even watch it? That makes a lot of sense,” he teased.
“It’s Abernathys,” she corrected.
“Whatever.”
Janie moved closer as the lamp light caught her freckles and patient shadows lingered along the wood-panel walls.
“Listen. You can watch it, just not for long.”
“Why?” Scott asked.
“According to Debbie, you must switch the television off before they…” Janie paused, thinking about her next words.
“Before they what?” She now had Scott’s full attention.
“Before they see you,” Janie said through gritted teeth.
“Sorry babe, what does that mean? How can they see you?” Scott asked with narrow eyes.
Suddenly, the television audio hissed into life. The colourful stars and stripes were no more; instead static danced across the screen to the low hum of white noise. Scott and Janie stared at the TV, then back at each other.
“That’s the thing. I have no idea. It’s just what I heard.”
“OK,” Scott said after a few moments. “So what happens if they see you?”
“According to Debbie’s cousin…” Janie paused, thinking about how her next words would land. “You die.”
The basement den fell silent, bar the white noise from the TV.
Scott began to laugh nervously. “Oh come on babe. You don’t believe that do you? I mean where’s the proof? And besides, if anyone can stay up and just watch this show, then surely there’d be people getting killed all across town?”
“It’s not always there.”
Scott did little to hide his puzzlement. “What do you mean?”
“Well…,” Janie said, “it’s not guaranteed that the Abernathys will appear. Debbie said she’s tried it dozens of times, but she’s never found the show.”
“So what makes you think it’ll work for us?”
“Look, if you’re too scared to try it, you’d better go turn the set off now in case they appear?” Janie teased.
“I’m not scared,” Scott protested as he stood. “I just think it’s stupid – and more importantly, I think we should go to bed.”
Janie took a deep breath then smiled at Scott in defeat.
“Alright, you win. It’s probably a load of BS anyway. Take me to bed.”
She held out her arms as Scott lifted her off the sofa. He pulled her close and their lips came together. Janie flung her arms around his neck as his hands moved down to her waist. They stood like that for a moment, enjoying each other’s embrace, Janie’s bare feet pressed firmly into the carpet.
Worn movie posters such as The Empire Strikes Back, Raiders of the Lost Ark, and the Thing were displayed haphazardly across the wall beside them. Music posters from groups such as AC/DC, Journey and The Police were also part of the collage. The Journey poster was particularly tatty and looked like it had been through the wash.
“I’ll get the TV,” said Scott as he gave Janie another kiss.
Janie began to straighten the cushions and watched as Scott knelt before the screen. He reached for the knob, and as his fingers brushed the plastic dial, the static fell silent and the dancing grains disappeared. He froze.
A soft jingle began to play out through the speakers as a black and white image took shape across the screen. Scott fell on his behind and shuffled back toward the sofa. Janie sprang onto the cushions like a startled cat and took up a defensive pose behind her knees.
“What the hell…” Scott stuttered.
“This must be it,” Janie whispered, her voice a little shaky.
“What do we do?” asked Scott.
“Wait…” Janie reached out and guided him back to the sofa.
The image on the screen settled to reveal a still picture of four smiling faces. They belonged to a man, a woman and two children: a boy and a girl. The man had dark hair slicked over to one side and was well presented in a charcoal suit. He sat on a sofa and next to him was the little girl. She appeared to be around the age of nine and wore a light-coloured bow in her hair. Over the man’s left shoulder stood the woman. It was clear to see that she was the little girl’s mother. She wore a polka-dot dress and pearls around her neck, and even though the image was in black and white, her lipstick was clearly a rich shade of red. The boy peered over the man’s other shoulder and was a cheeky version of his father. He was smartly dressed in a check shirt and rested his elbows on the back of the sofa. Although he wasn’t wearing a suit like his dad, it was clear to see the resemblance. If the boy was older than his sister, it could not have been by much. But what gave real life to the image was the flowing, slightly slanted 1950s sitcom lettering that curved across the screen. It read ‘Up late with the Abernathys.’
Janie and Scott sat closer together and watched on in amazement.
“Should we turn it off?” he asked.
“It hasn’t started yet,” Janie said, her hand trembling with a mix of fear and excitement.
Then, as the jingle continued its soft whimsical melody, lyrics were added to complete the score. They were sung in a soft female voice.
“The hour is late, so you know it’s true… there’s a special show just waiting for you.
We’ve got Roger, Nancy and Toby too… but don’t you forget little Annie Lou.”
The melody continued for a few more seconds before more lyrics were added to the song.
“They’re a wholesome, American family… It’s time – for Up late with the Abernathys.”
After a few more seconds of the soft, playful jingle, the image on the screen faded along with the music. Then the Abernathys’ living room appeared.
Also read: Loser’s Leap
“This is crazy,” Janie said, her tone subdued. “Debbie is going to freak.”
A burst of applause erupted from an unseen audience, accompanied by a few cheers. The camera shifted and appeared to be centred more on the dad – Roger – as he sat in an armchair reading a paper. Then the view slowly zoomed out to take in more of the room. Soon, little Annie Lou could be seen cross-legged on the carpet playing with a doll.
“This is so weird,” Scott whispered.
As the camera settled, Nancy Abernathy walked into the shot. She was dressed in the same polka-dot outfit she had on during the title screen.
“Roger, dear,” she said in a voice soft and honeyed, “have you seen my pearl earrings?”
Roger looked up from his newspaper. “Do you mean the ones in your ears, darling?”
“Yes, those are the ones,” replied Nancy, to which the offscreen audience laughed hysterically.
Her husband returned to his paper.
“Well, have you?” Nancy asked once more.
This brought out an even louder chorus of laughter from the audience before Toby skipped into view holding a small mirror.
“Here, momma,” he said cheerfully as he held it up for her to see.
“Oh, heavens to Betsy, would you look at that. Thank you, Toby, dear.”
Right on cue the audience burst into laughter once more.
“You’re welcome, momma,” Toby replied.
Janie and Scott sat transfixed at the screen.
“This is ridiculous,” said Scott.
Back on the screen, Nancy had taken a seat on a sofa next to her husband’s armchair. Soon after, Toby came to join her. Annie Lou was still cross-legged on the floor, while her father began to fold away his paper.
“Right, Abernathys, I think it’s time to see what’s on the box,” said Roger, his voice rich with theatrical enthusiasm.
A cheer vibrated through the television speakers and thundered around Scott’s basement den.
“Um, I think we should turn it off now.” Janie began to panic.
“One second, babe,” said Scott, as little Annie Lou made her way toward the screen.
She reached out a hand, then the TV made a clicking sound. When satisfied, she returned to her position on the carpet.
“Turn it off!” Janie yelled.
Scott stiffened at his girlfriend’s sudden change of tone and froze through a mixture of fear and confusion.
“Oh look, the picture’s coming…” said Nancy Abernathy cheerfully.
“Scott!” Janie screamed.
Scott dived toward the TV and reached out for the power knob.
“There we go,” boomed Roger Abernathy.
It was too late.
Scott found the knob and turned it. Nothing happened.
“Scott, what’s going on?” Janie asked with pure panic.
“Look, Daddy,” Annie Lou cried, “he’s trying to turn off the TV.”
The rest of the family laughed but this time the audience remained silent. It was as though they weren’t there anymore.
Scott shuffled back to the sofa and Janie wrapped her arms around him as tears began to swell behind her eyes.
“Can they see us?” she stammered.
Through the screen Toby laughed and turned to his mother. “Oh, I love it when they say that, momma. They always say it.”
“I know, darling,” she replied, her smile packed with perfectly white teeth.
“What the fuck is going on?” Scott stuttered through trembling lips.
“Pull the plug,” Janie whispered in his ear.
“What did she say?” asked Annie Lou.
“I’m not too sure, sweetheart,” Roger replied as he uncrossed his legs and sat forward in his chair.
Without hesitation Scott sprang from the sofa and raced to the side of the TV. He fell to his knees and grabbed the power cable close to the wall socket and yanked it free. For a moment there was nothing but silence. He looked back at Janie as she cowered behind her knees. Then he saw the pure fear on her face as tears began to stream down her cheeks. Then came the laughter.
Scott peered back at the screen. “What the fuck!”
The Abernathys were still there, each one laughing and smiling. Toby even had his finger pointed at the screen.
“That’s always my favourite bit, dear,” chuckled Nancy as she rested her hand on her husband’s arm.
Janie screamed behind her hand as tears continued to run down her face. Scott was white as a sheet. He slowly stepped away until he stumbled into the sofa. Janie grabbed him from behind and pulled him close.
“Look, dear,” said Nancy smoothly, “isn’t she a pretty little thing?”
Roger’s smile widened. “She sure is, darling, especially when she cries.”
That brought on another bout of laughter from all the Abernathys.
“I do love her pink sweater,” added Nancy.
“Look, Pop,” called Toby, “he’s wearing a shirt just like mine.”
“Indeed he is, son. He appears to be a young man of good taste. I sure hope nothing bad happens to him.” Roger winked over at his son.
Janie and Scott began to shake in each other’s embrace as more laughter escaped the TV.
“What do you think is going to happen, Daddy?” asked little Annie Lou with pure excitement, her smile unwavering.
“We need to get the fuck out of here!” barked Scott.
All Janie could do was sob through her tears, then stumble as Scott dragged her to her feet. The steps up out of the basement were only a few feet away.
Meanwhile, Roger looked over at his daughter and said, “I know exactly what’s going to happen, Annie Lou.”
“Come on!” Scott panicked.
“What, Daddy, what?” asked Annie Lou impatiently as she cuddled her dolly.
Suddenly, Scott yelled Janie’s name as she unexpectedly pulled him away from the stairs and back into the heart of the room.
“Why, Scott’s going to die, of course,” Roger replied matter-of-factly.
Scott froze as he stared at the screen. “What?”
Janie was on him in an instant, the pencil gripped tightly in her hand. Scott had no time to react and screamed violently as blood poured from his right eye socket. Quickly, Janie ripped the pencil free as Scott scrambled to cover his face.
Cheers and laughter from the Abernathys fought to overcome Scott’s cries of agony but ultimately failed. As he hit the floor and rolled onto his back, Janie was on him again in seconds. This time, she went straight for his neck.
It was hard to tell just how many times she had stabbed him. In the end, the pencil simply gave up and snapped. Blood seeped deep into the burnt-orange carpet and specks of crimson had peppered the posters along the wall. The attack had gone on so long, even the Abernathys began to lose interest.
“Wasn’t that marvellous, dear?” Nancy said in her almost whimsical tone.
“Splendid, darling,” said Roger as he made himself more comfortable in his chair. “Did you enjoy that, kids?”
Both children cheered with joy.
“That was a really good show, Pop,” Toby replied as he leaped down to be with his sister. “You’re so good at guessing what’s going to happen.”
Janie’s hair was matted with blood and hung in sweat-filled strands around her face. Her eyes were wide and bloodshot and her hands shook, soaked in her boyfriend’s scarlet essence. She remained on her knees, straddling his lifeless body. Her heart pounded in her chest and her breathing came in short sharp bursts.
“That’s going to be a hell of a mess to clean up,” Nancy said as she stood up from the sofa.
“Sure is, darling,” agreed Roger as he picked up his newspaper once more. “Kids, how about we leave Janie to it.”
“Oh, alright,” Toby moaned.
“Can we watch one more, Daddy? Please?” pleaded Annie Lou.
Roger looked up at his wife who simply smiled.
“Alright,” he said as Toby and Annie Lou cheered. “We can watch one more.”
Without delay Annie Lou dropped her doll and crawled over to the TV. On the other side of the screen Janie remained on top of Scott’s body but turned her head just in time to see Annie Lou reach out a hand, and as it went out of view… Click.
The screen died. The silence was deafening. Janie coughed and gagged as she blinked away tears. Stunned, she looked around the basement as if seeing it for the first time, before lowering her eyes to what she had done. Then, as her boyfriend’s blood began to pool around her knees, she screamed.
Credit: Neil Driscoll
Please note the author of this Creepypasta does NOT give permission to be reproduced in any other medium
Copyright Statement: Unless explicitly stated, all stories published on Creepypasta.com are the property of (and under copyright to) their respective authors, and may not be narrated or performed under any circumstance.