November Discussion Post: Which Creepypasta Would You Like to See as a Movie?

Add this post to your list of favorites!This month’s discussion post topic was suggested by YOU CAN’T HANDLE THE USERNAME!, and it’s an interesting one:
Of all the Creepypastas/Crappypastas that you’ve read, which would you like to see as a film? Do any specific actors, actresses, directors, composers, etc, come to mind for your imagined Creepypasta movie adaptation? Would it be a short film or full-length?
Have fun with this, and thanks for the idea, YOU CAN’T HANDLE THE USERNAME!


I wanna see the Jeff stories as a movie(s). I think they’d be pretty good.
Jack Stenrin(Quote)
Report comment
Yes but it would be hard to get the full description of him.
Huntercoch(Quote)
Report comment
I actually really like the holders series
Ziodes(Quote)
Report comment
Oh, wouldn’t that be cool? I think it’d be hard to get the true descriptions of some of the rooms and people, I can think of a few that would need some major special effects and CGI. Besides, the Holders doesn’t really have an ‘ending’. It just goes through the motions of how to get the artifacts, not what to do with them, and it never specifies exactly what would happen when they come together. Still, though, a little creative story telling and editing, and even that could come out kind of neat
Proudly Insane(Quote)
Report comment
what they should make into a movie is Zalgo cause it can even have a open ended ending
Lord Gore(Quote)
Report comment
Jeff-The-Killer
Detected By Tim Burten
Alisha(Quote)
Report comment
I am sorry I meant to vote positively for your comment but I derped up and voted thumbs down.
Maelstr0m(Quote)
Report comment
Yeah… I like that idea.
Anonymous(Quote)
Report comment
DEFINITLY MAN!
COOLZ(Quote)
Report comment
I would love to see a "Jeff The Killer" as a full-length movie starring Kane Hodder or Dave Bautista!
Spenser(Quote)
Report comment
I love jeff the killer :D!!!
Emily(Quote)
Report comment
Jack nicolsen should play Jeff! He does do a great job in movies with crazy guys!
Someone(Quote)
Report comment
I wanna see a slender man movie with 3 slender man stories that really happend.
Japanga(Quote)
Report comment
I’m surprised no one suggested The Cave, it’d be great to see a good Lovecraftian style horror movie.
TomyShotgun(Quote)
Report comment
I would love to see Dear Abby as a movie with Lauren Ambrose as Abby and Jeremy Sisto as Jay.
Milo9084(Quote)
Report comment
Awww yeah. I could totally see him in the role. You’d want to sympathize with him at first, but then he’d also make an excellent psycho.
La Mettrie(Quote)
Report comment
the rake
yoyoman(Quote)
Report comment
I would love to see Bedtime,Mr. Widemouth, of course slenderman, and there was one with a screaming girl in the mans dreams and the girl was dancing to a sond and she was spinning instead of dancing, maybe even Dear Abby too
WellDoneSir(Quote)
Report comment
WHO WAS PHONE?
sorry i had to do it
Joey G(Quote)
Report comment
Psychosis has to be the one. A short film would work, but Psychosis was good because of the build-up. Let’s slow his descent into madness to about an hour long movie. It’s perfect.
Colorless(Quote)
Report comment
Sorry but honestly if a creepy pasta was made into a movie it would sort of have to be Jeff the Killer.
Maelstr0m(Quote)
Report comment
Jeff The Killer, obviously.
FreakShow358(Quote)
Report comment
Ben
Gabe(Quote)
Report comment
I’d like to see karma as a movie. Anyone remember that one?
To mama(Quote)
Report comment
Woops I meant to call myself YO mama
Yo mama(Quote)
Report comment
day of all blood
sam(Quote)
Report comment
BEN Majora’s Mask Ben.
Trystan(Quote)
Report comment
Isn’t it obvious which ones should be made into movies?
1. Slenderman.
2. The Rake.
3. You could probably turn Psychosis into a movie if you tweaked the story to make it longer.
That will be all. Ooh, wait, instead of saying "that will be all", I’ll sign off by saying this, my favorite quote from a really cool guy:
"Stay beautiful, because ugly people suck."
[Burnsy, you're so awesome lol]
Terracotta Pie(Quote)
Report comment
slenderman for SURE
Zoe(Quote)
Report comment
Slenderman or Jeff the killer for sure. There both very popular characters and many people would love to see a movie about them together working as a team.
Kayla(Quote)
Report comment
Slenderman and Jeff the killer! If there were movies for those I’d die happy.
Anonymous(Quote)
Report comment
Slenderman and Jeff the killer! If there were movies for those I’d die happy.
Renee(Quote)
Report comment
Has anyone said Ben drowned yet? Starring Mickey Rooney and Andrew Garfield? Anyone?
Jerfy(Quote)
Report comment