November Discussion Post: Which Creepypasta Would You Like to See as a Movie?
This month’s discussion post topic was suggested by YOU CAN’T HANDLE THE USERNAME!, and it’s an interesting one:
Of all the Creepypastas/Crappypastas that you’ve read, which would you like to see as a film? Do any specific actors, actresses, directors, composers, etc, come to mind for your imagined Creepypasta movie adaptation? Would it be a short film or full-length?
Have fun with this, and thanks for the idea, YOU CAN’T HANDLE THE USERNAME!
I imagine Dust could be made into a movie quite easily… It is so well written, it just feels like it could be adapted really well with very little change.
Others however, like Candle Cove… Those would probably be a lot harder without changing the basic idea of the whole thing.
Whichever, though, I’d prefer short film. Those are the best at driving something home, and leaving a lasting impression. At least that’s my opinion.
I agree that it would fit better as short films, perhaps part of an anthology.
i dont know how to right in so im doing this and im going for "the house". the one with like the zombie guys
I agree, Dust is one of the best written story in CP history
i would like to see all the jeff the killer series to be turned into a movie due to the fact that the only reason i discovered you through it.
actually, if you got bedtime with all five parts you would have enough material for a good long movie i reckon.
For sure. All the bedtime stories could easily make a movie.
what about a move whith slenderman and jeff.
if your talking about a fight slender man would win cuz he’s yah know invincible and jeff isn’t so no but if like your being friendly and they’re a team then maybe i like the idea but its a no go sorry
Ya I like that idea slender could find Jeff walking around in a forest looking for a cabin the they find one the girl wakes up sees Jeff then sees slendy and then she passes out
ya me to that would be cool
Even better if Jane the killer is in it too
I agree. Jeff The Killer would be a great movie.
jeff the killer would suit the fit relly good as far as im seeing
of course you would think that, but I have to agree. Seeing kids murder each other sounds very entertaining.
That’s the hunger games
Your totally right!!!!! Hahahahaha
I think I laughed to hard so hard that I have a headache 
I guess you could say that but it’s your opinion
ya it could be jeff 1 would be jeffs origin then jeff 2 could be about jane the killer then in 3 they could fight but i also would like to slender man since every one is talking about him and iv also have another idea how about slender vs. jason i mean like i would say slender vs. jeff but we would know who won cuz jeff can be fiscaly harmed but like slendey and jason can only be spiraly harmed so who the fuck would win?
Please learn to speak English, and then come back. Or I can just throw a dictionary at your face, whichever one you prefer.
jeff you forget the story of jeff the killer is how he becomes a killer.. Maybe if the maker if this creepypasta makes another we can make it into a movie
I could see Darren Lynn Bousman directing a Jeff movie, it’s up his alley.
Well, if it helps. I am making a jeff the killer movie on youtube! Thanks for your time jeffrey… Your friend, -Draven The Killer
That sounds coll I’m gonna check it out right now
I agree with that, a movie about Jeff’s story would be a really good idea.
I agree with that, a movie about Jeff’s story would be a really good idea.
I think Harlequin NO.7 would be the best choice do to its lenth and how well written it is.
Harlequin No.7 seems too incomplete for a movie though.
Jeffy would be best. All the gore. YUS.
Tails Doll would be perfect for a movie
I agree and I think the one when the guy marries that girl that ends up being crazy and killed her former husband and kids while recording it on her computer in the basement
would make a great suspense/horror film regardless of how many films have been made similar to it
Definitely the Russian Sleep Experiment. There are so many good stories on here though! ヽ(ﾟДﾟ)ﾉ
The Russian Sleep Experiment was freaky. I loved it.
hey i agree with you! it was so creepy!
I felt uncomfortable reading it… It was great!
I agree, the Russian sleep experiment would make a great movie. It’d be worth the money.
The Russian Sleep Experiment would make such a good movie but theres one that’s slightly similar to it already made into a movie but still a great idea!!
What movie is that?
I agree, The Russian Sleep experiment has an awesome storyline, and a clear ending; it would be perfect for the big screen!
that would be a great fantastic idea but from what viewpoint like would it be from one of the researchers or would it be told from one of the subjects or it could be like you just see everything happen
Jeff the killer is perfect for a full length horror movie.. especially because he becomes a badass psycho killer! Let Hollywood choose the actors but i would really love to see it on screen..
i agree with you. i would love to see jeff the killer on thee big screen. it should be about like how it all started at the beginning and then going into other things.
Iwould like to see jeff and smile dog
Yeah like Smile Dog is Jeff’s pet…
You can imagin the title cant you?
“GO TO SLEEP”
Jeff the killer played by heath ledger..oh wait
sorry
That would be the best movie ever i can see it right now “Go To Sleep” Jack the Killer played by heath ledger that would be a big sell
i agree. With all the stories about jeff i think it could go as far as a mini series… Possiblly. you know with Jeff vs. Slenderman,Jeff vs. Jane the killer it all seems like real good idea on paper but then again hollywood has a way of changing things.
I agree I say the warning would be a good one.
Jeff the killer is a great story so it will be a great one (go to sleep) 1 great line and a scary as crap
Jeff the killer is a great story so it will be a great one (go to sleep) is 1 scary as crap line and his face is horrific.
Thats not enough for a movie though
i agree too many times to breath
totally agree. It would beb like shane dawsons "smiley" but x5 better
Yes that movie would be amazing! I would defiantly watch that!
lol, they should get jake short, that would be hilarious.
did you know you can get jeff on minecraft
yeah its a creepy pasta mod
hmm… Maybe! It would be really cool to capture that crazy mind switch on film! >:)
yes jeff the killer would be an awesome movie. i would be the first to watch it
i totally agree with you!he’s just one badass killer
thank you now go to sleep
i cant. too light out.
U CANT TROLL HEROBRINE!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
the first one would be him becoming who he is and killing major targets, and the sequel would be when he faces jane.
If they make a Jeff the Killer I think I’ll die and go to haven! He’s my favorite and (might I add) One of the sexiest Killer there ever was. <3
yes great idea for a movie
“GO TO SLEEP”
Jeff the killer played by Heath Ledger… oh wait.
aw :C
a movie would be great but what about an anime series depicting his life from the begining and taking ever single pasta about him a seprate episode or multi part episode for longer ones like jeff vs jane
Yes! That would be a great idea! I love anime and it would make a ton of money.
same here totally agree
YES candle cove and jeff. i could see and end where he looks at the camra and says “Go to sleep!” then it ends
I highly agree with you. Jeff the Killer would make an amazing slasher film!
I think Johnny depp should be Jeff
Soooooooo….. I’m not the only one?
This is what I would definitely go for
heath ledger would be ideal for that movie. he plays such a good sinister role only when jeff started killing he was 13 plus heath ledger commited suicide. he was the only reason i watched batman. rest in peace
Day of all the Blood. Oh wait….
http://www.creepypasta.com/day-of-all-the-blood-the-movie/
Come on, it’s creepypasta, a short film is the ideal here! Some of the creepiest films I’ve seen have been short ones.
I’d vote for The Strangers (I believe it’s called), about the man who gets tricked into riding an infinite inter dimensional subway system. That was an amazing read and, in my opinion, would make a great movie
yeah but the ending would be awsome but what about what hollywood might do to it thats why jeff or slender man might make a better movie
The same could be argued of your Jeff or Slenderman idea, Ryser.
I think that Psychosis would make an excellent short film or one-hour movie. It has some serious potential to be either extremely well produced and amazing, or terrible.
I second this. Actually kinda surprised no one else suggested this yet…
I completely agree, that is still one of my favorite pastas on here.
Agreed, Psychosis (though not my favorite) was my first and creeped me out the most.
I don’t know. The man’s writing is the most important part of the pasta in my opinion, even if they used a voice over, I still think it wouldn’t work.
Yeah i was thinking psychosis would be a good movie but they would need to add on a little to make it like an hour and a half or so like give a backstory to the man and so on.
The Expressionless. Played by Kristen Stuart. Lolololl.
No but seriously, Mr. Widemouth of the Woman In the Oven would be amazing.
I think Expressionless would make a great short film.
I see you’re a “This Man” fan. Haha, I was gonna say I think that that pasta would make a good psychological thriller if more investigation was done.
Btw, he intrigues me. Kinda like an incubus is what he seems like to me.
Yes A TMF (This Man Fan) indeed! And in fact you’ll be happy to know a horror movie about This Man is being produced! Check it up on wikipedia! Produced by Sam Raimi.
epic
For me, it’d have to be Tulpa, but only if they don’t make it all cheesy and weird and stick to the original feel of the story.
Also the Lemon-blossom Girl over from Ichor Falls could be a good sort of mystery- horror-thriller but it’d have to be a short film or it might drag a bit, I might make it myself
This x1000000000
I was thinking this, but I did some research and apparently it’s a pretty heavily used idea. Not that specific scenario per se, but pretty similar. Still love that story though.
In any of these, we would need morgan freeman to narrate.
the day of all the blood…narrated by morgan freeman.
although i dont think he can speak in caps lock, so samuel l. jackson might be more appropriate.
I would really like to see a rake movie. Or maybe Candle Cove. And of course, who doesn’t want a Slenderman Movie?
Agreed lot of games… but no movies. why is this?
We need someone to make a candle cove series
Oh yeah the rake would be a creepy movie
im pretty sure someone already made a rake movie
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bj1E8DlNuW0
I think they already have done an slenderman movie. I think its called “vindigo” or something like that. Also “the blair witch project” is based on slenderman.
I think there’s some movie called “The Entity” based on the Slenderman mythos in the works… don’t know when it’ll come out tho..
I actually saw the trailer, doesn’t look too good. No doubt it’ll end like most horror movies, where the guy and girl meet, both are connected to the antagonist. Then they “fall in love” or whatever and manage to kill the bad guy in some retarded way. Everyone dies but them and they go skipping off into the sunset.
The Mummified Head is wide open with opportunity. You could enhance the movie industry with a masterpiece such as that. If anyone has any screenplay for it, I will feature you as co-producer and director with me. This is a BIG money opportunity.
Well, I know when I’ve been scammed
Imma get right on that. How can I contact you, Steven?
Think about a situation in which one must end ones own life in order to gain true knowledge and power. I think there actually could be a movie somewhere in there lol.
I think some of The Slenderman stories could be made into a movie quite well. I would have Kristen Stewart playing the Slenderman’s victim because she is such a useless actress. I would also cast myself (hope I don’t sound too big headed) as The Slenderman’s accomplice – I know in the creepypastas he doesn’t have an accomplice but I have read a load of fanfic where he does and it works quite well!
Watch: ‘Proxy; A Slender Man story’ By Mike Diva. By far the greatest slender live-action.
no Kristen Stewart should be slender man! she has no facial expression so she would be perfect…
Wrong. Even Slenderman has more facial expression as her. Lolsy lol lol.
A while ago I started a slender-man movie script and it started off with two brothers running and playing in the forest and one of the brothers ran the other way and went deeper into the forest and he runs into slenderman. Then that kid gets killed and the other kid (his name is eric) sees the slenderman killing his brother,Then it goes to what eric saw,Then he tells them the description of slender-man, Then it goes to when eric is 16 and its wouldve been his brother’s birthday then Eric decides to investigate in that forest and nobody believes him and things keep happening. I am still writing this movie.
I wanna see that….so badly.
Damn. Hard decision. Mr. Widemouth would make a good short movie. And Secret Faith of the Spiders would make a great long movie. Especially loved that one.
i would like to see psychosis
I’d love to see Jeff the Killer become a movie. But since there are already so many murderer movies already, I think I’d rather see someone make a Squidward’s Suicide Spongebob Episode.
true but there would be some copyright issues.
They already have a Squidward’s Suicide on Youtube. It’s called Red Mist, but it isn’t very good
I’m not the least bit ashamed to say I’ve been practicing computer animation by trying to make a Mr. Widemouth short cartoon. And I thnk we all know what this comments section will be spammed with: marble hornets did such a good job, we should be seeing a Slenderman movie soon.
Not as an animation though, I’d prefer if it was a movie. A full length horror movie of Slenderman. If it is a horror animation though, well at least it should be a full length horror animation film, not a short horror animation film.
If it was animated it could also be by Tim Burton. I love his style. The scene on Corpse Bride when Victor is running through the woods with his long stick legs… yeah. That would be great for Slender…
Slenderman* Not slender.
I don’t know this idea got in my head, but what if Slendy was afraid of heights. lols
Actually, an indie Slenderman film was made. I haven’t seen it, but it’s called "Wendigo". Not sure why though… Completely different monster. you can watch the full film on youtube
Oh wait. Happy Appy. DO. IT. NOW! Glad everyone likes the idea
I’d like to see Ickbarr Bigelsteine as a movie, it would be so freakin’ awesome to see socks play the lead!
This. This. A Thousand times this!
also, If Cry could be the actor I would throw all my money at them
That would be awesome!!!
Heck yea! xD
Dear Abby
great idea
Kisaragi Station…
You could have the comments narrated in the background, with Hasumi being a shadowy person.
zhttp://www.creepypasta.com/kisaragi-station/
If God’s mouth had more characters it would make a great movie. Unfortunately it’s hard to make one of those characters die one by one movies when you only start with two.
How has no one said Who Was Phone? Starring Nicholas Cage?!?
Twist, Liam Neeson was phone
He found you.. and killed you!
kristen stewart can play the coveted role of “yur honey”
What ’bout u derpbutt?
I’ll have to think about this one for awhile.
Please do.
BUTTON DAY!