The realtor said it was ‘a steal’. Newlywed couple, twenty-nine and thirty, freshly out of their cramped city apartment, wide-eyed with love and future and starter-savings.
A sunny cul-de-sac. Green grass like AstroTurf. American flags on even-numbered houses. White fences on the odds. Mailboxes with identical brass numbers. “You’ll love it here,” the realtor beamed, gesturing like she was selling heaven and not a two-bedroom home with a warped porch step. “It’s a community.”
They moved in on a Monday.
They were greeted by the neighbors and they all seemed nice.
By Wednesday, the neighbors had brought six casseroles. All different, all warm, all too heavy to politely decline. They smiled too wide. Joan from next door cupped Joleyn’s face like they were long-lost sisters. “You must be so tired from the move,” she said. “I left chamomile tea on your nightstand. Helps with the nerves.”
They hadn’t given her a key.
On Friday, Lucas came out of the shower to find Glenn from across the street sitting on the couch, flipping through their mail. “You forgot to forward some of this,” Glenn said casually, like he lived there. “Don’t worry. I flagged the important ones.” He wore socks but no shoes.
That night, four neighbors arrived with wine, uninvited. “We heard music through the walls,” Linda said. “Sounded lonely.” They stayed until past midnight, laughing too loud, touching every book on the shelves, one of them flipping through Joleyn’s journal like it was a coffee table magazine. When she yanked it away, he smiled. “Oh, I just wanted to see what makes you tick.”
The next morning, a handmade wreath hung on their front door. Flowers, twine, a tiny paper heart in the center with “WELCOME FAMILY” written in red ink. No one claimed it.
Then things started to vanish. Not stolen. Just… moved. Joleyn’s toothbrush ended up in Lucas’s sock drawer. The remote in the fridge. A clump of hair -not theirs- curled neatly on the pillow between them. They stopped sleeping well. The walls felt thinner. The air, heavier. Someone left a pie on their kitchen counter one morning. Still steaming. No note. No footprints.
The dog from three houses down began sleeping in their backyard. Joan said, “He chooses where he feels safe. Animals know.”
Joleyn started locking the doors. Lucas stopped mentioning when he saw shadows move past the windows at night. “They’re just friendly,” he said once. “Friendly doesn’t mean dangerous.”
She stared at him. “Doesn’t mean safe either.”
It came to a head on a Thursday. Joleyn had been working from home, headphones on, when she caught movement out of the corner of her eye. She looked up and saw Joan in the backyard, holding a pair of pruning shears, trimming the rose bushes with the care of a mother grooming a child. A moment later, Glenn walked into the house with a Tupperware of soup, calling out, “Chicken and thyme! Good for cloudy days!” without waiting for an answer.
Joleyn walked out onto the porch barefoot, hair frizzy, hoodie on inside out. Her voice cut the air. “Stay the fuck out of our house!” The silence was instant. The street froze like a dollhouse. The mailman, mid-step, paused and turned away. Glenn stopped moving. Joan looked up slowly, blinked once. “We’re just trying to love you,” she said.
The next morning, all the blinds in the house were open. They didn’t open them.
No more waves. No more casseroles. No more “good mornings.” But now the silence had teeth. A crow was nailed to the oak tree out front. Joleyn found the word ALONE scratched into the inside of their mailbox. Lucas pretended not to see it.
The pressure built. Joleyn started locking herself in the bathroom just to breathe. She kept the radio on all day. Lucas, who used to joke about the “perfect little cult,” now helped trim hedges and talked about how “neat” everyone’s lawns were. One morning, the trash cans had been bleached and returned to the garage even though they hadn’t taken them out. Lucas didn’t mention it.
That afternoon, Joleyn found him fixing Joan’s sprinkler system, shirtless, grinning. She said nothing. He said, “I’m just being neighborly.”
That night, she packed a bag.
Lucas stayed.
He started wearing polo shirts and khakis. He joined the HOA (Homeowners Association) board. He started jogging. He never used to jog. At the next cookout, he wore an apron that said Kiss the Cook and flipped burgers with one hand while the other clutched a beer. The neighbors laughed at everything he said. They smiled like they’d won. No one mentioned Joleyn. No one ever did. Not even her husband.
But one overcast afternoon, a dusty rental car pulled up to the corner. Parked. Engine humming. She sat inside, sunglasses on, face unreadable. She watched him.
Lucas stood on a new porch, handing over a foil-covered tray to a nervous young couple. The woman clutched her husband’s arm. Lucas grinned.
“We’re so glad you’re here,” he said. And he meant it.
Credit: Meadow Steele
Copyright Statement: Unless explicitly stated, all stories published on Creepypasta.com are the property of (and under copyright to) their respective authors, and may not be narrated or performed under any circumstance.