Tuesday, March 19, 2019
Creepypasta

Left Behind

Please wait...

MORE TOP RANKED STORIES WE THINK YOU'LL ENJOY:

  1. Psychosis ★ 9.17 Rating (19218 votes)
  2. The Seer of Possibilities ★ 9.16 Rating (7435 votes)
  3. He Who Wanders ★ 9.16 Rating (387 votes)
  4. Mr. Widemouth ★ 9.14 Rating (8705 votes)
  5. Bedtime ★ 9.14 Rating (11049 votes)
  6. Artificial ★ 9.13 Rating (1872 votes)
  7. In the Walls ★ 9.13 Rating (1737 votes)
  8. Bound ★ 9.13 Rating (857 votes)
  9. The Burned Photo – Part 2 ★ 9.13 Rating (1128 votes)
  10. Slum ★ 9.13 Rating (1189 votes)

    Share this creepypasta on social media!
    Estimated reading time — 3 minutes

    Barbara was sure the ritual worked. She stood up from the pentagram as 5 wicks slowly swirled their smoke in the room. The weather seemed angry—lightning flashed and roared through the coastal home, and suddenly the lights went out.

    “Damn the power. Let him come” she thought to herself as she calmly went downstairs in the dark. She prepared some tea on the stove, and waited.

    As her chamomile steeped, she again thought about how unfair it had been to take him so soon, only 8 years old. Sure, things hadn’t always been easy, but… she had put the bottles away. Things would be different, now.

    She heard three distinct knocks at the front door. Excitedly, she ran to swing it open, only to find no-one there. She left it open as a welcoming invitation. Knocks from the back door drew her to the spot, only to find that doorway empty as well. She left it open, too, mist from the rain collecting on the tile floor.

    As she was about to take a sip, she felt a presence behind her. He was here! She whirled round to see her boy: his face was obscured by shadows, but his brown shaggy hair and favorite flannel shirt marked him well enough. She ran to hug him and found he was incredibly heavy, much heavier than she remembered him only a few weeks ago.

    “Hello Mommy,” said Michael.

    “Oh! My boy! Things will be so different, so much happier, now that you’re here! Do you want—”

    “I want to play a game. Mommy.” Michael interrupted. There was something unnatural in the tone he used for the word. “Why don’t you run… and hide. I’m going to catch you! This will be a LOT of fun.”

    “Are you sure you—”

    “DO IT,” his voice boomed through the house. Uneasily, she agreed as Michael began to count. She was going to hide in the pantry when she heard a growling noise, like the low rumble of a distant earthquake. She realized it was coming from Michael. As he counted, she realized she may have made a mistake.

    “15, 14… you better hide better than that, Mommy. Some things are better left as they are. But I’m here, now.” His boyish voice became more and more tinged with that horrific, low grumble. The sound of a blade pulled from the kitchen butcher block alerted her ears to danger. Yes, this had been a mistake. Intense claps of thunder blocked further sound as she raced upstairs to the master bedroom, and locked the door. Like a child, she cowered in the closet and waited.

    “10, 9, 8… I don’t know why you’d want me back, Mommy.” She heard his words as leaden feet ascended the stairs. “You weren’t nice to Michael. 7, 6, 5, 4…”

    She started to cry frantically, curled in the corner of her closet. She was trapped. She felt as if she couldn’t breathe as the locked bedroom door easily sprang open.

    “3… 2…”

    Silence. She listened as the storm calmed outside and a whisper emanated from directly behind the closet door: “In fact, Mommy, Michael hates you. That’s why he left you behind… and sent me instead.”

    The door flung open and a bolt of lightning illuminated rows of jagged, glinting white teeth crowding Michael’s mouth like a shark’s jaw.

    The storm subsided. Her tea grew cold.

    Credit To – Skyla2186

    Please wait…

    If you enjoyed this story, please share it on social media!

    Click here to check out Creepypasta.com's official YouTube channel

    SIMILAR STORIES

    RANDOM PASTAS YOU MAY ALSO ENJOY

  11. The Disappearance of Otis Jiry ★ 8.33 Rating (46 votes)
  12. Becoming a Killer ★ 8.93 Rating (54 votes)
  13. The Dognapper ★ 7.28 Rating (134 votes)
  14. My Sister Brought Home A Clown ★ 7.82 Rating (169 votes)
  15. The Thing in the Window (Illustrated Creepypasta) ★ 6.79 Rating (95 votes)
  16. The Hourglass Tattoo ★ 8.56 Rating (153 votes)
  17. Don’t Install the Hangman App ★ 7.59 Rating (141 votes)
  18. The Unfortunate Life of Jamie Robert Mitchum ★ 8.06 Rating (154 votes)
  19. The Old Lie of the Dead Lands ★ 7.69 Rating (75 votes)
  20. The Portal in the Woods ★ 7.76 Rating (131 votes)


  21.